Three brothers guilty of damaging property
AT the end of a three-and-a-half day trial in Castlebar Circuit Criminal Court last week, three brothers were convicted of damaging the front door of a house, but cleared of damaging the sitting room window of the same house.
Three brothers guilty of damaging property
AT the end of a three-and-a-half day trial in Castlebar Circuit Criminal Court last week, three brothers were convicted of damaging the front door of a house, but cleared of damaging the sitting room window of the same house.
Two of the three had also pleaded guilty to damaging three cars which were parked outside the house, while the third had pleaded not guilty to damaging the cars. He was, however, found guilty on all three counts of causing damage to the cars, while all three were found not guilty by direction of the judge of aggravated burglary and assault, arising out of the same incident on October 22, 2007, at 38 The Fairways, Castlebar,
During the trial, in which over a dozen people gave evidence, the court heard of a series of incidents between a group of friends and Declan, Francis and Shane Munnelly from Snugboro in Castlebar, with the judge telling all involved at the end that he did not like what he was hearing in relation to the conduct of some people on the streets of Castlebar. He warned all involved that there better not be any recurrence of the type of events which led up to the incident on October 22 last year.
The three stood accused of going to 38 The Fairways at 4am on that date, smashing the glass panels of the front door and the sitting room window, entering the house via the smashed window and assaulting Patrick Rice – also known as Ricky Rice – who was inside, and also of smashing every window in three cars outside which belonged to Louise Hopkins, Fergal Boyle and Patrick Rice.
There were six charges in total levelled against each of the accused – four for damaging property, one for aggravated burglary and one for assault – with Declan and Francis Munnelly pleading guilty to three charges of damaging property – in respect of the cars – and not guilty to the rest. Shane Munnelly pleaded not guilty to all charges before the jury of eight men and four women.
In evidence, Declan Munnelly said he did not break the main window, but did break the smaller ones around the front door with a golf club. He had pleaded not guilty to damaging the house because he maintained he had not touched the sitting room window, but upon discussions with counsel, Judge Groarke informed the jury that they could consider breaking the main window and door windows as two separate events, and could find the defendants guilty of one or the other if that was the way they felt. Ultimately, this is the decision they came to.
Declan Munnelly said that he and Francis were out that night and a scuffle broke out outside Mantra night club where both of them had been accosted. Later, they rang Shane – who was not out – to bring them home and on the way Francis received a phone call about a party in 38 The Fairways, to which they went. When they arrived nobody would answer the door and then Patrick Rice pulled back the curtains in the sitting room and started tapping the window with a golf club and shouting at them to go away. He had been outside the night club and was friends with Mark Hopkins who, according to the Munnellys, had started the fight outside Mantra. Declan Munnelly’s evidence was that next thing the window shattered from Patrick Rice tapping it and Francis pulled the golf club off him and threw it into the garden. Declan then said that he picked the club up and lost his temper and began smashing the car windows and the door windows of the house. His evidence was that he did all the smashing, while Francis was present but did not help out. He said Shane never got out of his car.
The evidence of Francis and Shane Munnelly corroborated that of Declan. All of the Munnellys said that they do not play golf and do not own golf clubs.
Louise Hopkins said that she was in bed in 38 The Fairways that night when she was awoken by shouting at 4am. She said she looked out her window and could see the three defendants, with Francis and Shane holding golf clubs, and Declan holding a hammer. She said she watched as her car was smashed up by Declan Munnelly while his two brothers hit the sitting room window with golf clubs. Two of the other occupants of the house were not at home when the incident happened, while Louise Hopkins’s boyfriend Chris Foy was at home and said he saw Shane Munnelly swinging a golf club.
His brother Cathal Foy said he was in the sitting room with Patrick Rice but had gone upstairs and saw none of the defendants. It was Patrick Rice’s evidence that he had no idea who was fighting outside Mantra but when he was back in 38 The Fairways he heard shouting and opened the curtains to see Shane and Francis Munnelly standing there with golf clubs. He said Shane broke the window and then came in through it, and Francis hit him on the back with the golf club and broke the club. He said that Francis then head-butted him twice and Shane hit him again with a golf club. It was his evidence that Declan then threw a hammer into Francis and said ‘take his kneecaps off’.
Garda James Daly said he found the occupants of the house in a distressed state, and felt that Patrick Rice was in a shocked state. Similar to the Munnellys, all of the occupants of the house said they did not play golf or own golf clubs.
Around 4pm on the fourth day of the trial the jury was sent to deliberate and returned about an hour later, with guilty counts on all charges, except the breaking of the sitting room window – for which they returned not guilty verdicts in respect of all three defendants.
Sentencing will take place next term, with probation reports to be completed on all three defendants in the meantime. As a condition of their bail the Judge warned the defendants that they must not consume alcohol in the meantime.