Those pictures


Everyone believes they have the ‘definitive’ point of view on the Brian Cowen paintings episode.
ONE quiet Wednesday afternoon a few years ago, I took a call from an angry mother. I was News Editor at the time and my colleague in sport was fortunate enough to be out of the office.
The lady wanted to vent her anger at someone, and she duly did – at me. The source of her anger was a photograph of her daughter that appeared in the paper of the previous day. I was aware of the photo because my colleague in sport had asked my opinion on it on publication day and I said I thought it was excellent, as it was an action photograph that conveyed all the effort and exertion that went into being a winning athlete. My colleague held a similar view, the conversation ended and the photograph was published, alongside many others from the same event.
It was clear that the woman on the phone did not concur with our editorial views. I explained as best I could that there was no intention to offend, that the context of the photo made it one of excellence in terms of capturing a live sporting moment and that, really, her daughter did not look silly. That hadn’t helped her that morning, she countered, as she tried to coax her tearful teenage daughter out the door to school. She believed she would be bullied because of the photo and didn’t want to go, her mother explained.
There was nothing I could say or do to make the awfulness of that belief any better for the woman or her daughter. We had looked at the photo as journalists, the angry woman on the phone looked at it as a mother whose daughter was hurting.
I thought of the episode last week when the controversy over the Brian Cowen paintings was in full swing, and in particular on Friday night when the matter was discussed on ‘The Late Late Show’. On the Late Late panel were Nóirín Hegarty, Editor of the Sunday Tribune, the first paper to publish the photos; Senator Rónán Mullen, comedian Alan Shortt, and Fianna Fáil TD, Mary O’Rourke. While the other three were strenuously defending their own points of view (Shortt that it was humorous and everything humorous was defensible, Hegarty that it was newsworthy and acceptable political satire, Mullen that it was offensive, unfunny and non-satirical as it made no political point) and at pains to dismiss the views of those who disagreed with them, Mary O’Rourke – for me – made the most worthwhile contribution. Stressing that she was neither narrow-minded nor prudish and that she had no objection to political satire (and also admitting that she felt ‘silly’ over her own ‘I was in the bath’ response to a question on Morning Ireland some years ago, which was subsequently satirised in many quarters), Mary said that what troubled her most was the thought of Brian Cowen’s wife and children seeing those paintings staring out at them from newspaper pages and from their TV screen.
The debate that has raged over this matter for the past week has, in my view, been over-reactionary and the main problem with the episode is everyone’s belief that they have the ‘definitive’ point of view on the matter. Personally, I didn’t like the paintings. I saw no great artistic or satirical merit in them and I felt sorry for Brian Cowen and his family having to see them and endure the protracted debate about them. But I had no objection to Conor Casby’s decision to paint them or hang them in two prominent galleries as a prank; it achieved what he wanted as an artist: publicity. Nor did I object to Nóirín Hegarty making an editorial decision to publish them. I had no problem either with RTÉ running the story and then apologising for it; the embarrassment was theirs. And I see no reason why Eoghan Ó Neachtain and Michael O’Kennedy weren’t entitled to be offended, on behalf of their party leader, at what they perceived as the indignity of the stunt and the publicity that surrounded it.
Freedom of expression is important in any democracy. So too is the right to be hurt as a human being and to register that feeling with those who hurt us. Both should be protected and accepted.