The limits of doing it on your own


In the first of a series of features on industry in Mayo, Westport – a town that has been proactive but claims to have had little assistance up to now – is under the spotlight.
When doing it on your own has its limits
In the first of a series of features on industry in Mayo, Westport, a town that has been proactive but claims to have had had little assistance up to now, is under the spotlight. Neill O’Neill reports.
WESTPORT is in danger of not receiving direct foreign investment in new company start-ups until at least 2020, unless the Oireachtas committee currently considering ‘What is required to develop the west’ calls for a change of Government policy to ensure the town is given the same development priority as others in the country.
Under the 20-year National Spatial Strategy (2002 to 2006), gateway towns and hub towns in Ireland are given priority when it comes to inward foreign investment, and, critically, Westport has neither status. Consequently, a move is currently under way locally to have this issue addressed.
A Multi-Agency Task Force was set up in Westport in the wake of 325 job losses in Allergan in 2005. Comprised of members of the Town Council, Chamber of Commerce and people from across a range of local businesses, its remit is to engage with local and Government agencies – mainly the Industrial Development Agency (IDA) – to positively promote Westport as an attractive location for investment and company start-ups. The group was recently contacted by the Oireachtas committee who wanted to know what progress they have made as a committee for the town in recent years, the current position and readiness to accept new industry and investment in Westport, and what their views are on ‘what is required to develop the west’.
Myles Staunton is a Westport town councillor and a member of the Multi-Agency Task Force. He feels that if the Oireachtas committees fail to recommend a change of Government policy, it will be left up to the business people of Westport to try and attract investment to the town. However, given that Westport meets most of the prerequisites desired by potential investors and remains a highly attractive location in which to invest – despite its lack of gateway or hub town status – he remains hopeful that the new 38-acre IDA business and technology park in the town will soon have more occupants.
“The difficulty for a town like Westport that is trying to attract investment is that we are outside the Government priority,” he said.
“The fact that our concerns will be included in a report that is going to the committee caught our attention because Oireachtas committees can work very well when they are not just a talking shop. Their reports can have significant consequences and have had transforming effects in the past. We saw this as an opportunity to appraise them of exactly what work we have been doing in Westport to try to promote enterprise and entice new investors into the town.”
The remit of the Oireachtas committee is to look at a few things in particular. These are infrastructure of areas in the west and public service deficiencies, any impediments to job development, sectors for initiatives and job developments and interventions required to regenerate the west.
According to Myles Staunton, there are several criteria that must be met before a town can say it is ready for inward investment. At a recent IDA conference, he was informed that there are three prerequisites that must be fulfilled in order to attract investment.
The first is that an advanced unit is absolutely necessary and full planning permission has been granted for a 1,152 square metre unit at the new business and technology park adjacent to Allergan. It is hoped this will be built next year and Myles Staunton feels that ‘once it is we will be in a better position to speak to investors as the red tape and bureaucracy will be out of the way’.
The second thing you need is the right people and skills locally. Westport Town Council has made a provision in its most recent local area plan for a population of over 13,000 people – including the surrounding hinterland and towns like Newport and Louisburgh. “There are plenty of skilled people in these areas who have worked to certain standards and received the highest level of training,” according to Myles. “We had a stand at the recent ‘LookWest’ expo in Dublin and have the right materials on the right desks in the right companies, which sends out the message that there will be no skills shortage in Westport if investors come here.”
The third element is that the right infrastructure needs to be in place. Established industries in the west have long been voicing their frustration with the NRA about the condition of the N5 road linking the east and west of the country.
At present, consideration is being given to changing the route of a proposed upgrade to the N5 – with further delays inevitable – but progress has been made on other sides. Five train services daily from Westport to Dublin – including an early bird train – were recently announced by Iarnród Éireann, while the air route between Knock and Dublin has been restored to further enhance access, much to the relief of the Multi-Agency Task Force, who feel they have done all they can in this area.
“The new N5 is critical to our aspirations and every public representative in the county has been pushing for it, but, that said, the type of industry we are looking to attract could be high level services like software, people rather than products, so I wouldn’t underestimate the Knock to Dublin link and the train. People could work in Westport and still be based in Dublin,” said Cllr Staunton.
“We need to emphasise how much we have progressed the situation, that there is a very serious group made up of councillors and significant players among the business community in Westport. We have lobbied everywhere we can – examples are in relation to gas, the ESB line; we’ve had initiatives like the 3D model with Google as well, and have engaged with the IDA up to now. It is a three-stage process.
We asked them what we needed to do and have done as much as we can. Now we need to know what the Oireachtas committee is looking at and what are they going to do for towns like Westport which are not hub towns or gateway towns.”
With Westport frozen out by the National Spatial Strategy, the feeling locally is that the town is not getting due credit for laying down a marker and doing so much proactive groundwork to promote itself to investors. Basically, Westport needs to be on a level playing pitch with hub towns. While the IDA and other groups like Enterprise Ireland have engaged with the Multi-Agency Task Force, they are not responsible for the Government policy they must adhere to, and all the work that has been done to bring Westport to the high level of suitability it is at for inward investment could be for nothing, if the Oireachtas committee does not take these concerns on board and help Westport overcome the obstacles it faces.
This is so critical, because, as Myles Staunton points out, the only real alternative is one that will not be a simple task.
“If the Oireachtas committee does not come up with something radical – along the line of what the public accounts committee came up with before – then either the park remains empty, with all the groundwork we’ve done wasted, or what it will take – and this may have to happen – is that local individuals or companies go out and attract the investors themselves. Despite the economic turmoil, Ireland is still an attractive place to invest with low corporation rates and Westport has a lot to offer – and is ahead of many hub towns in certain regards.”
“We have established and successful industries and Westport is a wonderful place to live with great amenities and a great community spirit,” he added. “To be locked out of a 20-year spatial strategy is extremely disheartening for the town. It would be a pity if the advance unit was built and left empty. ”
Embracing technology-driven employment locally
HUGHES FAMILY EXPERIENCE
Neill O’Neill
CATHAL Hughes is Chairman of the Hughes Group of companies – and a key member of one of Westport’s best-known indigenous business families. He feels that Westport is a hugely attractive place to invest and live in, but has seen from his own experiences that the face of modern business is changing.
Earlier this year Portwest closed its local manufacturing facility, ending a tradition of clothes-making in the town that spanned close to seven decades. Cathal Hughes said he feels Westport must now look to attracting a new breed of industry to the town, in the areas of technology and research and development. While all industry and investment – including manufacturing – is to be welcomed, Mr Hughes feels that attracting people to Westport to work in such skilled and specialist areas will not be a problem, and it is here that the future lies.
“We ceased manufacturing at Portwest in Westport this year and there were some job losses,” he said, “but we have been employing more specialist staff since then and are nearly up to the same number of overall employees now. All the staff at our new headquarters (incidentally the only building on the new 38-acre IDA Business and Technology Park) are people with specific skills and our local operation is all technology-based now.”
Portwest now employs people in areas such as design, IT support, internet catalogue development, purchasing, accounts, marketing and product development. It is a company that is always recruiting, but has shifted from looking for general manufacturing and production personnel to highly-skilled people with specific talents and qualifications.
“We are keeping a strong skill base locally, but it is becoming increasingly hard for companies to keep the more traditional industries alive, and we have moved from maintaining manufacturing jobs in Westport to technology-based employment,” added Cathal.
He also feels that Westport has the potential to develop many more jobs through the tourism sector – and not just in hotels. Top of his wish list is to see a marina developed at Westport Harbour, which he feels would create huge potential and benefits for the town. Several studies had indicated the feasibility of this. It is also his belief that the building of the proposed advance factory at the IDA park would be a massive boost to the town, and for the prospects of inward investment and employment.
Quality of life is key to Westport attractiveness
MEDICAL SERVICES CENTRE
PROFESSOR Ray Kinsella is on the faculty of the Smurfit Graduate School and the Management Institute of Paris. In the past he has put forward his belief that Ireland should develop an International Medical Services Centre which would create thousands of jobs, based on a format similar to the IFSC in Dublin. He strongly advocates Westport as the ideal location for investing in such a centre.
He feels that the eastern seaboard is top-heavy with hospitals and inward investment and the infrastructure cannot cope with what is already there.
Meanwhile, in the Westport region there is access to a major airport, road and rail links, plenty of good schools and housing – with planning permission granted for sites where hundreds of more houses could swiftly be built. What is also very important, Professor Kinsella contends, is the attitude and mindset of people in Westport, which is one that is enormously open.
“There are social facilities and the type of research-driven approach to improving quality of life in Westport, in areas from planning and development through to tourism, which is very rare,” he said. “The environment locally is one that is open for business and a good quality of life is essential for attracting a high quality workforce.”
“Westport’s success in competitions like the Tidy Towns proves that the community is thriving,” he said, stating that having an aesthetically pleasing town beside the sea will never act as a deterrent.
“A common sense approach by companies looking to invest should not be underestimated,” he said, “and Westport has the breadth of vision and quality that could anchor any number of companies to the town. The first question a HR representative from an interested company would ask is: ‘is it a nice place to live?’, followed by ‘would I like to bring my kids up there?’.
“The answer to both, without any reservation, is yes, and to be able to say this with conviction is a testament to the appeal of the town and to the fact that Westport has the space and capability to attract investment to the town and keep companies and people there.”