The Irish Schindler


Monsignor Hugh O'Flaherty is credited with securing the safety of over 6,500 Jews and allied soldiers during World War II.
“Monsignor Hugh O’Flaherty is credited with securing the safety of over 6,500 Jews and allied soldiers in Rome during the second world war. He has been dubbed the Oskar Schindler of Ireland”
Second Reading
Hitler’s desire for the ultimate genocide of the Jewish people created an enormous challenge for Christianity. Throughout history, Christian-Jewish relations have usually been uneasy, often antagonistic and rarely harmonious. Yet Christianity stakes its claim as a religion based on the concept of agape, a love that extends to each individual, regardless of difference, equal respect as a child of God.
The recent marking of the 50th anniversary of the death of Pope Pius XII has re-ignited controversy on his response to the terrifying predicament faced by the Jewish people during the second world war. Supporters of Pius XII argue that he did everything he could, within the knowledge and resources at his disposal, to condemn Nazism and provide sanctuary for Jews. Opponents assert his response was weak and paltry and governed more by the political imperative of protecting the Church from Nazi attack rather than the moral imperative of acting strongly against evil.
No definitive resolution of the matter can emerge until the Vatican archives for the period are opened fully to independent scholars. Admittedly, the Vatican has released some volumes of documents from the second world war. These documents were chosen by Vatican historians and do not necessarily give an accurate account of these years.
There is, however, no ambiguity about how one cleric, an Irishman, responded to the dark force of Nazism. Monsignor Hugh O’Flaherty is credited with securing the safety of over 6,500 Jews and allied soldiers in Rome during the second world war. He has been dubbed the Oskar Schindler of Ireland.
Schindler, you may recall, the subject of a film by Steven Spielberg, was a German industrialist who saved several thousand Jews from death, through a variety of stratagems. O’Flaherty, too, has been the subject of a film, ‘The Scarlet and the Black’, starring Gregory Peck, and a recent biography by Brian Fleming.
O’Flaherty, from County Kerry, was born in 1898. He studied for the priesthood in Rome. Ordained in 1925, he was posted to work in the Vatican diplomatic service.
He moved in important circles in Rome. He was the amateur golf champion of Italy and played regularly with Count Ciano, Mussolini’s son-in-law. As a diplomat, he served in Egypt, Haiti, San Damingo and Czechoslovakia.
By 1941 he was back in Rome where he was given the task of visiting prisoner of war camps in Italy to report on the conditions of those held there. Through Vatican radio he released names of prisoners, a source of consolation to families in the allied countries. He noticed that medical care was poor and that there was a shortage of Protestant chaplains for British soldiers who had been captured.
He was successful in remedying these situations, so successful that Italian fascists lobbied the Vatican for his removal from the post.
As the Vatican agreed to this request, O’Flaherty returned to Rome where he and some friends placed over a thousand Jews in safe locations. Among his supporters was a Mayo woman, Delia Murphy, the ballad singer, the wife of the Irish Ambassador to Italy, TJ Kiernan.
When Italy withdrew from the war in 1943, 18,000 prisoners escaped from their camps. Many of them arrived in Rome where they sought help from O’Flaherty, whom they remembered from his visits to their camps. He and his friends provided them with secure accommodation.
His actions won the unwelcome attention of the Gestapo. Kappler, the Gestapo chief, ordered his capture, should he venture out of the neutral confines of Vatican city. There was an assassination attempt on him.
O’Flaherty continued his philantrophic work with the insouciance given only to the truly brave. To avoid capture, he adopted a variety of disguises – a road sweeper, postman and coal man. He even ventured on a form of religious transvestism by dressing as a nun.
When the war ended, O’Flaherty insisted that the Allied troops treat German prisoners with respect. “God has no country,” he said. He was honoured by the US, British and Israeli governments. He continued to work in the Vatican until ill health forced his retirement to Kerry in 1960, where he died three years later.
O’Flaherty’s life illustrates the validity of Edmund Burke’s dictum that all that is necessary for the triumph of evil is that good people stay silent. In 1994 a grove of Italian trees was planted in Killarney National Park in his honour.
Brendan Kennelly wrote a fitting poem for the occasion:
“There is a tree called freedom
And it grows somewhere in the hearts of men,
Rain falls, ice freezes, wind blows,
The tree shivers, steadies itself again.
Steadies itself like Hugh O’Flaherty’s hand,
Guiding trapped and hunted people day and night,
To what all hearts love and understand,
The tree of freedom upright in the light!”