The cost of cutbacks in common sense

Westport’s thorny Garden of Edenplaceholder image
Westport’s thorny Garden of Eden

De Facto There is a proliferation of PR gurus and spin doctors to respond to every critical comment or statement, to counteract fair comment.

Liamy MacNally

THERE is a proliferation of PR gurus and spin doctors to respond to every critical comment or statement.  There is so much time, effort and money spent on trying to counteract fair comment.  It would be easier for the Government, Departments and statutory bodies to admit failure when it looms large.  Instead, they attempt to convince us that the reality that actually exists is only a figment of someone’s imagination.  Bury the truth at all costs.  If truth cannot be buried then at least lower a veil over it.  Pick up any paper, listen to any radio current affairs or news programme or watch television and the story is the same.  The doctors of spin are busy administering their medication.  Corrective surgery has a whole new meaning.

This time last year the HSE spin doctors were gung-ho for commentators who were critical of the reality of cutbacks.  The Patient Transport Scheme is one example.  They denied point blank that there were cutbacks in the scheme.  Earlier this year they denied that any plan had been introduced to implement cutbacks in front-line community care services.  Enter the stark reality of the actual letters received by various community groups outlining the need for cutbacks.  Truth can pull the veil apart.

The HSE is now on a cutback crusade to save upwards of €300 million.  That is a lot of money and it will affect front-line services.  It has to.  No amount of spin can paint any other picture.  Absenteeism costs the HSE €150 million per annum.  Even with over 100,000 employees it is still a significant amount of money.  In the cauldron of cutbacks it is huge.  Absenteeism has the double effect of losing the services of the employee and the need to employ another person on overtime to replace the person who is off work.  The absent employee gets paid (with some exceptions) while not working and someone else gets paid (often at overtime rates) to ensure the work is carried out, hence the huge cost.

The cutback train has now arrived at the Mayo General Hospital station.  Mr John O’Mahony, TD, had some stark news for people with his claims that the cutbacks decision will impact on patient care services at the Mayo General, just as it will impact on all hospitals.  Cutbacks are being implemented because the hospital has to ensure savings of over €2.5 million before the end of the year.  It seems that coming in on or under budget has become the new mantra of the HSE.  This mantra was not started at a local level but is emanating from the Department of Health and the upper echelons of the HSE in the plush, performance-bonus powered offices of Dublin.

While the Mayo General has been attempting to implement savings through certain measures since the start of the year it will have to find another €2.5 million approximately before the end of the year.  These will affect patient services.  Five nurses on temporary contracts were let go from the Mayo General last Thursday, according to John O’Mahony.  Are there others facing the P45 crunch and is this just the beginning? 

Losing nurses means that wards will be closed.  So what excuse will be offered to sick people?  You cannot get a bed because we have to implement cutbacks.  This is daftness of the highest order.  The cutbacks in the Mayo General will affect all sectors with children in danger of becoming victims also.  No one in management can say that the Paediatric Ward will not be affected.

While one can have sympathy with management at a local level who are faced with HSE circulars from HQ this type of thinking has to be resisted.  The only people who are adversely affected by cutbacks are those who are ill.  What does this say about our society?  What does it say about Government policy?  Governments will only implement what the people let them away with.  At the same time as cutbacks are being implemented performance-related bonuses are being paid to some senior HSE staff.  This is Bongo-Bongo land mentality.

Meeting the budgetary deadlines appears to be the HSE’s aim rather than provide services to those who need them.  According to Castlebar Cllr Michael Kilcoyne a person should only get sick at the start of the year when budgetary cutbacks have not risen to the top of the agenda.  To think that cutbacks are being implemented with winter approaching does not bode well for those who will require health services. 

Rather than let people know directly what is planned the HSE will spend time, effort and money denying that cutbacks are being implemented.  The HSE top brass are masters of the three monkeys approach to reality – hear no evil, speak no evil, see no evil. 

Related topics:
Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice