The betrayal of universality

Westport’s thorny Garden of Edenplaceholder image
Westport’s thorny Garden of Eden

De Facto Why should a Government begrudge people who have been financially successful? It just shows that this Government views everything in terms of money.

The betrayal of universality by this Government

DeFacto

Many people will hope to depart the charade of care for the elderly before they are barracked into filling forms. This ‘new deal’ for over-70s medical cards reduces elderly people to fiscal pawns. What a Government! And this is being done to save €16 million! There is no talk at all about the cost of implementing such daftness. On the one hand the Government wants to reduce HSE staff numbers, yet by introducing silly ‘loss of universality’ schemes it will have to employ people to police the silly forms. 

Where did it all go so wrong for Fianna Fáil? It is time to hear the voices of Beverley Flynn and Dara Calleary from the rooftops of Mayo on the loss of universality. It is time for the county councillors and the town councillors to learn to speak on the loss of universality. The loss of universality cannot be equated with a gain in the national coffers. It is the death knell for our commitment to caring for older people. It is we, as a state, putting a limit on care. Who gives a toss what older people earn? To hear the heartless cry from Government about how inappropriate it is to provide free medical care for richer older people. Get a life Brian Cowen. Is the State to be seen as the National Begrudger? We have sufficient begrudgery in the ripples of everyday life to last us for generations. We do not need the Government to make it into a national treasure. Why should a Government begrudge people who have been financially successful? It just shows that this Government views everything in terms of money. This is the Government that knows ‘the price of everything and the value of nothing’. Fear, vulnerability, anxiety, isolation and loneliness are the currency symbols this Government will leave as a legacy to future older generations.

The loss of universality has serious implications for older people. The principle of universality has now been lost and will have serious effects. The Government will gnaw away at it now that the principle is gone. Older people who are dipping their savings’ headlights on the horizon of the medical card threshold have serious worries. Is €16 million the price of putting so many people through hell? It has been stated here before and, no doubt, will be again, this Government is an affront to all things republican, yet it clings to ‘The Republican Party’ mast top with the grip of a drowning man. This Government has reduced republican ideals so low that they are ‘robbing people with the fountain pen’ rather than the gun.     

From now on people over 70 who are just above the medical card cut-off point will still face serious medical costs. The loss of universality will deny them specialist care that would have been available but now they will be unable to afford. It will render them unable to avail of health supports without paying for the services. Everybody knows (except this Government of rich people) that one of the greatest fears of older people is that they will be unable to pay for nursing care if they need it. This Government has consigned them to that abyss.     

By heralding the ‘new deal’ for medical cards for the over-70s the Government publicly abdicated its caring role for its citizens. The concept of universality has been broken, what will be next in line?  Government TDs and Senators should not have accepted the breaking of the concept of universality. It just shows that party takes precedence over principles. 

Since Budget Day the medical card fiasco has been changed (albeit not properly), the employment levy has been changed, the Disability Allowance has been changed, the Airport Travel Tax will be changed (guaranteed, because its proposal is so daft as to render it puerile), education cuts are shaky and we await the farmers! Good old Fianna Fáil: a lot done, more to do!   

Removing the universal availability of medical cards for the over-70s would save €100 million they said. The latest wheeze has ‘saved’ €16 million excluding ‘policing’ charges. What will that cost be? In real terms, what are the savings? Whatever it costs is it worth the price?

Related topics:
Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice