Suicide verdict recorded in inquest of popular Ballina priest

A verdict of death by suicide was recorded at the inquest on Thursday of popular Ballina-based priest Fr Muredach Tuffy

Suicide verdict recorded at inquest of popular Ballina priest

Edwin McGreal

A verdict of death by suicide was recorded at the inquest last Thursday of popular and well-known Ballina-based priest Fr Muredach Tuffy.

Fr Tuffy of The Newman Institute, Cathedral Road, Ballina, was found dead in the basement of The Newman Institute on the morning of Tuesday, October 30, 2012. The native of nearby Castleconnor, Co Sligo, was 39 years old at the time of his death. He was the Director of The Newman Institute.

Returning a verdict of suicide, Acting Coroner for North Mayo Dr Eleanor Fitzgerald said it was ‘important to allay rumours and suspicions’ which had circulated after Fr Tuffy’s death.

“It is not the purpose of this inquest to judge why. We must establish the facts and reach a verdict,” she said.

She said Fr Tuffy was ‘a very healthy and active man’ who was involved in the church and the community.

There was, she added, no note left by Fr Tuffy, and no intention declared to anyone. No one, she said, had any knowledge that this would occur.

Dr Fitzgerald said that as part of her work, she had spoken with Fr Tuffy’s medical doctor, who said Fr Tuffy had no history of any mental illness and that his only medical problem was hypertension.

Dr Fitzgerald said she had to be satisfied that it was death by suicide and the inquest could not just assume this. She said that all the evidence from the scene and from the post-mortem pointed to the fact that Fr Tuffy intended to take his own life.

She added that death by suicide was ‘distressing and shocking’ but ‘is a fact of life’.

“Although Fr Tuffy was a reverend priest, he was still a human person like all of us,” she added.

“Why, we don’t know. We want the answers at this inquest. That is not the purpose of the inquest, but sometimes having the answers may help … but I am afraid we don’t have the answers. That is a hard fact for people to accept, but it was his personal decision and no one else’s,” she said.

Bishop’s tribute

Fr Tuffy’s bishop, Dr John Fleming, was in attendance at the inquest together with members of Fr Tuffy’s family. Afterwards he issued a statement to the media.

“Fifteen months ago our hearts were broken and our lives shattered by the news of the death of Fr Muredach Tuffy. During these months his parents, his brothers and sisters, his fellow priests and his innumerable friends have lived through the pain of his passing and have tried to make sense of his death. Today’s inquest confirms that there is no answer to the why of his leaving us.

“With Fr Muredach’s death his family lost a wonderful son and brother, this diocese lost a deeply dedicated priest, the Newman Institute lost an outstanding Director, his parishioners lost a caring pastor and his friends a delightful companion.

“On behalf of his family, his priest friends and all whose lives he touched, I say ‘thank you’ for the support of your presence and your prayers. May he rest in peace.”

‘Did not seem out of sorts’

Conor Rowe was the last person to see Fr Tuffy alive. He said he passed him on the street on Monday, October 29, around midday.

“We acknowledged each other, and he did not seem out of sorts,” Mr Rowe told the inquest.

Gerry Hughes, a maintenance worker at The Newman Institute, discovered Fr Tuffy’s body in the car park in the basement of the institute. He said that when he arrived at work at 9am on Tuesday, October 30, the front emergency door was open, and that a drum of water was keeping it ajar. Supt Gerry Donnelly told the inquest that gardaí believed that Fr Tuffy left the door open so that people would have access to where he was.

Ballina Parish Secretary Julianna Doherty, who works close to The Newman Institute, said that when she heard screaming at 9.20am she went outside and was told Fr Tuffy had been found dead. She told the inquest she knew him since he was ordained to the priesthood and  formally identified his body to gardaí.

There was nobody else in The Newman Institute at the time of Fr Tuffy’s death, the inquest heard. Coroner Dr Fitzgerald and Supt Donnelly both extended their sympathies to the Tuffy family, his friends and to Dr Fleming, the Bishop of Killala.

Related topics:
Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice