Suicide problem ‘not being tackled’

Coroner and grieving Ballina father critical of Government who plan to introduce new death certs that omit suicide as cause of death

Suicide problem ‘not being tackled’

Coroner and grieving Ballina father critical of new death certs that omit suicide as cause of death

Anton McNulty

A MAYO coroner and a grieving Ballina father have described the decision to introduce new death certificates which omit the cause of death as a ‘retrograde step’ in dealing with the issue of suicide.

The new short form death certificates which leaves blank the manner in which a person died have caused controversy in recent days, with claims that they will not encourage people to speak out about suicide and fail to address any of the common reasons for suicide.

Ballina man John Higgins, whose 19 year-old son David took his own life in 2011, told The Mayo News yesterday that the introduction of the new death certificates was a ‘cosmetic exercise’ while coroner for south Mayo, John O’Dwyer described the decision as a ‘retrograde step’.

It is understood that in the last week alone in Mayo, there have been as many as three suicides reported to coroners. Nationally, coroners now say they deal with suicide more frequently than deaths brought about from road traffic accidents.

The new short-form death certificates which are being introduced shortly will not replace long certificates but are an additional option where a death has occurred as a result of suicide, drug abuse or violence. Social Protection Minister Joan Burton said the new death certificates will omit the cause of death to help prevent distress to loved ones.

‘Cosmetic exercise’

However, John Higgins said he is ‘at a loss to see how it will do anything for us’ and believes it is a ‘cosmetic exercise’ instead of dealing with the issues of how the death was caused.

“I look at photographs of David everyday and he is the first thing I think of in the morning and the last thing at night. You start to get on with life but you don’t forget.

“David’s death certificate is in an envelope in a drawer but how often will we use it? We used it once and we will never use it again. It is just a legal document. I see his headstone a lot more than I see his death certificate. I think this is a step back. No matter how you dress it up suicide is suicide. We know how David died but families should be getting more help from the Government in dealing with the issues. They are not tackling the problem head on as far as I am concerned.

“This is a cosmetic exercise and I am at a loss to see how it will do anything for us. At the end of the day the Government has to take responsibility and do something about it [causes of suicide]. I think they would be better off dealing with the facts that are written on the cert,” he said.

Retrograde

Many people believe the new certificates could do ‘more damage than good’ to prevent suicide prevention campaigns.

Coroner for South Mayo, John O’Dwyer, told The Mayo News that he does not believe the level of suicide in Mayo to be above the national average, but he does feel that the new death certificates could be a ‘retrograde step’.

“Apart from some comments made by the Minister in relation to it, I do not know what she is trying to do,” he said. “There is no point in burying it [issue of suicide] and it will be a retrograde step to do it. Are we trying to conceal the realities of life?” he said.

David Higgins died in March 2011 when he jumped from a bridge over the River Moy in the early hours of the morning after leaving a house party. His body was discovered following a 14 day search of the Moy and an inquest into his death heard that he had left the house party after drinking large amounts of alcohol and was upset when asked to leave.

Below cost selling

The coroner found that alcohol was a contributing factor in his suicide and his father John has campaigned for the Government to deal with below cost selling of alcohol in supermarkets. He explained that instead of dealing with death certificates, the Government should deal with the causes of suicide and tackle the alcohol problem.

“We have an answer in our case and in over 50 percent of cases alcohol is a contributing factor [in suicide]. I want to see the Government pay attention to what is on the death certificate and deal with it. We are calling on them to deal with the issue of the availability of cheap alcohol.”

John believes that the Government can introduce legislation dealing with the availability of cheap alcohol in supermarkets, similar to the way the smoking ban was introduced, but he questioned the will of current Ministers to do so.

“The one person I had faith in was Róisín Shorthall. She did not entertain the drink lobby and was very good at her job. But she is gone now. I am not saying I am losing hope but I don’t think the political will is there. I get handshakes and sympathy from politicians and others, but I don’t need that, I want something done about it,” he stressed.

Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice