Spreading sludge on farmlands

Westport’s thorny Garden of Edenplaceholder image
Westport’s thorny Garden of Eden

The Food Safety Authority have published a report on the food safety implications of land-spreading materials.

The Food Safety Authority of Ireland (FSAI) published a report last year – “Food Safety Implications of Land-spreading Agricultural, Municipal and Industrial Organic Materials on Agricultural Land used for Food Production in Ireland.”  It states that Ireland has a total land area of just over seven million hectares.  Based on 2004 figures, Irish agriculture utilises approximately 4.3 million hectares of this total area with pasture land accounting for 2.2 million hectares, silage one million hectares and the remaining one million hectares used for rough grazing (i.e. 453,500 hectares), hay (i.e. 189,000 hectares), cereals (i.e. 310,200 hectares), potatoes and sugar beet (i.e. 44,400 hectares) and other crops, fruit and horticulture (i.e. 69,400 hectares). 

“Appropriately managed land-spreading provides a sustainable option for the utilisation of organic agricultural (OA) materials and some treated organic municipal and industrial (OMI) materials.  Such use is conditional, however, on the implementation of effective controls as detailed in this report and the consistent application of good practice at every level.  Otherwise, in the absence of these measures, the land-spreading of OA and OMI materials on agricultural land used for food production may pose risks, associated with microbiological and chemical hazards, to food safety.”

The report states “the use of both OMI and OA materials, may pose risks to food safety from microbiological or chemical hazards.  The possible sources, type and routes of exposure to microbiological or chemical hazards that can contaminate food and water supplies either directly or indirectly through land-spreading are varied.  OMI materials such as sludge are more likely to contain chemical contaminants, e.g. metals, than OA materials.  There are gaps in current knowledge concerning the transfer of chemical contaminants and pathogens into the food chain through land-spreading of OMI materials on agricultural land used for food production… Current best practice for treatment and management of OMI materials from urban wastewater treatment is stipulated in the Department of the Environment, Heritage and Local Government’s (DEHLG) Codes of Good Practice for the use of Biosolids in Agriculture. However, these codes have no statutory basis since the current legislation does not define treatment options and associated process conditions nor makes reference to suitable code(s) of good practices or standard(s).  The report draws attention to the absence, in Ireland, of statutory controls or uniform standards for natural biological degradation processes including composting of OA and OMI materials that would be necessary for consistent effective treatment of such materials.  The absence of standards is a recognised impediment to the appropriate use of composts in the Government’s National Strategy on Biodegradable Waste.

Human pathogenic micro-organisms present in untreated OMI materials can be recycled in the human population via food when these materials are used on agricultural land.  Therefore, the use of untreated OMI materials in any form on agricultural land is a matter of concern for food safety.  Current legislation restricts the use of untreated OMI materials only allowing certain untreated OMI materials to be used on agricultural land under prescribed circumstances.  However, this report recommends that all untreated OMI materials including residual sludge from septic tanks should not be allowed to be spread on agricultural land used for food production.”

The Independent Farmers Federation (based in Sligo) has made a submission to the Western River Basin District Project (based in Galway), expressing concern about the use of sludge on farmlands.  The submission quotes from the FSAI report: “Many gaps in current knowledge remain concerning the risk of transfer of pathogenic micro-organisms and chemical contaminants into the food chain through the practice of land-spreading of municipal/public treatment plant sewage or waste, in particular on agricultural land used for food production in Ireland.”

The farmers group is also concerned that “no account is taken in existing regulations of the fact that pathogenic viruses, along with parasites such as Cryptosporidium and tapeworm are resistant to some treatment processes…”

The report also states that codes of good practice relating to the use of municipal plant sewage/sludge in lands “…have no statutory basis since the current legislation does not define treatment options and associated process conditions nor makes reference to suitable code(s) of good practices or standards.”

The FSAI report also states: “The introduction of legislative limits to control inputs metals, organic pollutants and endocrine disrupting chemicals is fraught with difficulties.” This, the report states, “is demonstrated by the difficulties experienced by the EU in achieving consensus among experts in relation to agreeing new legislative limits for metals and organic pollutants considered necessary to update the current EU Sewage Sludge Directive.  DEHLG (Dept of the Environment) has also pointed out that administrative problems in the aforementioned process have resulted in delays to the Directives update and revision.  To date, consensus has not been achieved almost ten years since the review process was initiated.”  Welcome to the next big debate!

Related topics:
Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice