Some people driving at ’ridiculous speed’ on Mayo roads - judge

A Mayo judge has expressed concern over the way some individuals drive on the narrow and twisting roads of north Mayo.

Some people driving at ‘ridiculous speed’ on Mayo roads  – judge

JUDGE Mary Devins has expressed concern over the way some individuals drive on the narrow and twisting roads of north Mayo.

In Belmullet District Court last week, Mr Shane Devlin of Muinginguane, Barr na Trá, was acquitted of dangerous driving, while Mr Liam Tighe of Shraigh, Bunnahowen, pleaded guilty to a charge of dangerous driving.

After hearing evidence in the case, Judge Devins said this was not an isolated incident and that just that day she had been overtaken in the area by somebody doing almost 140km. She added that she noted the registration.

In evidence, the court heard that Liam Tighe had collided with another vehicle at Briska, Bangor Erris, on March 14, 2008. However, Shane Devlin also stood accused of dangerous driving after it was reported to Gardaí that he had overtaken a car at speed at Kilsallagh, Bellacorick, shortly before the incident.

A witness told the court that two cars overtook her – in a manner which caused her concern – and a few miles later she encountered an accident with one of these cars crashed in the road and the other stopped behind it. Garda Thomas Barron said that it was while he was investigating the accident between Mr Tighe and the other vehicle that the report of dangerous driving against Mr Devlin came to light.

It was put to the defendants – who each had passengers in their cars – that they were racing in the direction of Bangor Erris that day. Both denied this, and denied knowing each other.

Eva Healy was in the car with Shane Devlin at the time. She said they were travelling from Castlebar and were passed by two cars near Bellacorick. Later, they encountered the accident between a dark navy car and a silver car. She said that Shane Devlin’s car was also silver.

Cora Byron told the court that she was driving that day and was overtaken by two cars on a dangerous road. It was raining at the time and when she arrived at the accident she said that the occupants of the second car were still inside it. She said she knew there would be an accident after she was overtaken by the two cars and slowed to 25mph. She said the two cars also overtook a tractor and missed a lorry ‘by the skin of their teeth’.

It was put to her by solicitor Pat Moran – representing Shane Devlin – that his client got out of his car, rang the emergency services and got back into his car upon arriving at the accident. He added that the reason Mr Devlin’s car was so prominent in her memory was because she sat behind it in traffic for over an hour while the accident was dealt with.

Damian Conroy was the passenger in the car with Liam Tighe when the accident occurred. He said that they were returning from college in Sligo for the weekend and were not racing anybody. He climbed out through the windscreen after the accident and told a man he didn’t know how to call 999. Upon questioning by Judge Devins, he said that he and Shane Devlin were different ages, went to different schools and did not know each other.

The driver of the other car, Thomas Gaughan, told the court that he was going to Castlebar that day when two-and-a-half miles outside Bangor he saw a bright car in front of him and then the impact happened.

In his evidence, Shane Devlin said that two cars also overtook him near Bellacorick. He said that he overtook a van that day and later a jeep (Cora Byron’s vehicle) on the road but denied doing anything dangerous. He said he was never a friend of Liam Tighe’s.

Judge Devins felt that this evidence tied in with his statement and called his oral evidence ‘rock solid’. She said that the road in question is full of people who drive at ridiculous speeds and that Cora Byron was new to the area and unnerved by the overtaking incident on a wet day. Judge Devins felt that when Cora Byron arrived at the accident scene Mr Devlin’s car may have fitted her preconception and whilst she did her civic duty, the State had not proven that the defendant had driven in a dangerous manner. She dismissed the charges against Mr Devlin.

Regarding Liam Tighe, defending solicitor Michael Bohan said that the accident happened when the back of his car pulled out after he applied the brakes and hit Mr Gaughan’s car.

He said his client had come away from the accident in the worst position as he broke his leg and damaged his knee. He said that this caused particular difficulties for Mr Tighe as he was a world champion dancer. He added that Mr Tighe was unlikely to ever appear in a court again and pleaded for him to be given a chance.

Judge Devins said that Irish politicians had decided to introduce a mandatory disqualification for dangerous driving for a reason, but the defendant had made a case for himself. She asked Superintendent John Gilligan for his opinion and was told: “Liam Tighe is someone I admire as an individual. He met these charges head-on and has suffered the worst from it all.”

On hearing this, and a pledge from the defendant that he wouldn’t be in court again, Judge Devins dismissed the Section 53 charge of dangerous driving and convicted him of careless driving, fined him €500 and imposed an ancillary driving disqualification for a period of six months.

Related topics:
Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice