Solicitors guilty of misconduct

placeholder image

TWO Ballinrobe-based solicitors have been found guilty of professional misconduct for the second time in seven months, after both were employed by opposing parties in a traffc accident.

Ballinrobe solicitors found guilty of misconduct

TWO Ballinrobe-based solicitors have been found guilty of professional misconduct for the second time in seven months, after both were employed by opposing parties in a traffic accident.

The Solicitors’ Disciplinary Tribunal ruled last Thursday that Michael McDarby and Sean Acton, of Michael McDarby and Co in Ballinrobe, should be fined €500 each and made to pay one quarter of the costs of Mary Joyce-McCarthy from Church Street, Dunmore, Co Galway – who had made five complaints against Mr Acton and two against Mr McDarby.

The tribunal heard that, following a car accident in 2000, Mr Acton was representing the complainant, while Mr McDarby was representing another man who was injured in the crash. Ms Joyce-McCarthy said that she feared Mr Acton would be telling his partner in the legal practice what she had disclosed to him about the case.

Following the crash, Ms Joyce-McCarthy was advised by Mr Acton to plead guilty to a charge of careless driving. She then started a civil action in the case but didn’t proceed with it.

In her three allegations against Mr Acton, she said he failed to get the report of an engineer before advising her to plead; did not advise that a guilty plea could prejudice a civil action; and breached her confidentiality.

Mr Acton told the tribunal that from his knowledge of the District Court judge in question and from the fact that Ms Joyce-McCarthy had no recollection of what had happened, he would have been ‘astonished’ had there been no conviction if there had been an engineer’s report into the crash.

He said he stood by his advice to the woman and had never passed on information about her case to a third party. He said at the time of the accident, the issue of a civil action had not arisen, nor did it until she approached him some years later.

In relation to the conflict of interest, Mr Acton said he never discussed her case with his partner. Mr McDarby said the pair did their best to avoid conflicts of interest but said mistakes can happen, adding that he had no idea about Mr Acton representing Ms Joyce-McCarthy.

The tribunal found Mr Acton not guilty of the allegations about his conduct following the crash, but both he and Mr McDarby were found guilty of professional misconduct on the allegation of there being a conflict of interest – in that they represented two different sides in the same case.

Last February, the same tribunal found the pair guilty on professional misconduct charges, and fined them €25,000 each plus costs.

Related topics:
Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice