RTÉ cleared over FÁS Prime Time show

Leave it to Mr O’Brienplaceholder image
Leave it to Mr O’Brien

A Castlebar woman has outlined how her reputation has been damaged since her name was aired on a Prime Time special.

RTÉ cleared over FÁS Prime Time programme

A CASTLEBAR businesswoman has claimed that her reputation was ‘sullied’ after her name appeared on a RTÉ Prime Time programme which investigated FÁS’s management of funds for a number of social employment schemes in Castlebar.

Regina McGarrigle claims that the airing of her name on the programme as a member of Castlebar Care of the Underprivileged Ltd scheme, membership that she refutes, left the impression that she was connected with the ‘serious questions’ in the show.

In one of fifteen complaints sent to the Broadcasting Complaints Commission (BCC) arising out of the programme which aired on February 17 last, Mrs McGarrigle outlined how her reputation had been damaged as a result of the broadcast.

Thirteen of the complaints made were submitted by relations of the late Canon Paddy Curran, who was subject to a number of allegations in a programme which caused much controversy in Castlebar. All fifteen complaints were dismissed by the BCC.

Mrs McGarrigle claimed that in spite of the fact that she had told Mike Milotte of Prime Time in advance of the broadcast that she was not a member of the above scheme, her name appeared ‘on screen as a member of this scheme without any qualifying statement/information/explanation’.

This, she added, led to her association with many of the serious implications in the show.

“As a result of the reporter’s failure to highlight/mention this (that she was not a member of the above scheme), the impression given by the programme was that Mrs McGarrigle was connected with the ‘serious questions’ being raised in the show,” a summary of her complaint explained.

“Pejorative terms used in the programme segment included ‘cashing in’, ‘seriously wrong’ and ‘misappropriation of funds’, the implication being that she was connected with these. Since then Mrs McGarrigle has received an anonymous letter, disparaging comments etc.”

The effect of these implications were profound, according to Mrs McGarrigle’s complaint.

“As both a private individual and as a business person in Castlebar and a former President of the Chamber of Commerce, Mrs McGarrigle’s reputation had been sullied. It is obvious that this could affect her business. On a personal level, she now feels she can no longer collect the basket collection in the church on Sundays as she has done regularly for many years, as many in the town feel that ‘there’s no smoke without fire’ and that she somehow had her hand in the parish till.

“She is suffering unnecessarily as a result of inaccurate facts being broadcast . . . This has also led to hurt to her family and friends and has caused untold distress to her elderly parents and parents-in-law,” continued Mrs McGarrigle’s complaint to the BCC.

In their response RTÉ say that the document containing Mrs McGarrigle’s name was not compiled by them and was accessible to anyone under the Freedom of Information Act. It was, they added, not RTÉ who claimed Mrs McGarrigle was a member of the scheme, but the company themselves.

RTÉ also added that the document on which Mrs McGarrigle’s name appears ‘was featured solely because of another name on it, TJ Kirrane. Mr Kirrane’s name was actually highlighted by a standard graphic device, while Mrs McGarrigle’s was dimmed’.

RTÉ also dispute that Mrs McGarrigle told Mike Milotte in their initial telephone conversation that she had no connection with Castlebar Care for the Underprivileged.

The BCC did not uphold Mrs McGarrigle’s complaint. Their ruling said that while it would have been ‘preferable’ had Mrs McGarrigle’s name being blacked out of the document shown in the broadcast, the issue being discussed was ‘clearly evident’ to be that of payment to Mr Kirrane for training.

Fourteen other complaints were all unsuccessful. Thirteen members of the family of the late Canon Paddy Curran, who was subject to a number of allegations in the programme, cited the programme as ‘lacking in balance and fairness’.

Seven brothers, a sister, four nephews and one niece of the late Parish Priest of Castlebar filed similar complaints that the programme ‘failed to afford an opportunity to rebut the allegations made against the late Fr Curran and, in particular, failed to allow an opportunity to balance and contradict the allegations made by Mr PJ Nally, against the late Fr Curran, towards the conclusion of the programme’.

In response to the complaint of Gabriel Curran, a brother of the deceased, RTÉ say that they accepted the truthfulness of Mr Nally’s account for a number of reasons including ‘Mr Nally is himself a deeply religious man and a conscientious church-goer who had no known reason to lie about Canon Curran’.

RTÉ also added that ‘it has been established in the courts that deceased people do not have the right to privacy’.

In their decision the BCC acknowledged the concerns of the complainant but the Commission ‘was of the opinion that the broadcaster was not obliged to offer the complainant or the Executor of Fr Curran’s estate a right of reply’.

Martin Waters, who said he was erroneously listed in the same document as Regina McGarrigle, was also unsuccessful. However RTÉ did state that ‘in the event of Prime Time returning to the matter, Mr Waters would be offered the opportunity to clarify his position directly by way of interview’.

Related topics:
Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice