Ring argues against Kenny’s proposed TD cuts

Leave it to Mr O’Brienplaceholder image
Leave it to Mr O’Brien

Fine Gael TD Michael Ring has expressed reservations about his party leader Enda Kenny’s plans to cut the number of TDs.

Ring: Cut quangos not TDs

MAYO Fine Gael TD Michael Ring has expressed reservations about his party leader Enda Kenny’s plans to cut the number of TDs as part of a series of reforms to democratic functions announced over the weekend.

Kenny has put forward a series of draft proposals which include abolishing Seanad Éireann and reducing the number of TDs by at least 20 and while his Mayo colleague Ring has given his support to the overall proposals, he argues against reducing the number of TDs.

“I would be very cautious about the suggestion to lose TDs because we would probably end up losing a TD in Mayo,” he told The Mayo News last night. “We do need our TDs, we are democratically elected and we are effective. I would prefer if we looked at the quangos and that end of thing. I would be afraid that reducing the number of TDs would take even more influence out of rural Ireland. I’m behind the overall proposals so long as it doesn’t negatively affect rural Ireland.”

However he does support plans from Kenny that entrust local government with greater authority.

“Giving more power to local government is my language,” said the Westport man. “That’s what I went to the High Court for [to challenge the removal of the dual mandate for TDs]. There is no power in local government at the minute. There is no point giving so much power to a county manager. It must be through elected representatives of the people.

“Giving more power to local government certainly would take some of the slack off TDs to be able to work on legislation too but I’m a firm believer that there must be a mix. You must always have your ear to the ground. That’s what’s wrong with Fianna FΡil - they are out of touch with the common people.”

Ring also suggests that the office of President comes under scrutiny.

“I think it is no harm to debate how our democratic bodies work. I have to say I am surprised Enda didn’t look at the Presidency. We are looking into the merits of various functions of government so it is no harm to ask of the Presidency - do we need this?”

Fine Gael leader Enda Kenny unveiled the radical plans at Saturday night's Fine Gael Presidential dinner in Dublin. The core tenets of the plans are to abolish Seanad Eireann, to reduce TD numbers by at least 20, to reduce the pay of Irish politicians, to reform the expenses system and to redistribute power from ‘the Executive to the Oireachtas; from Central to Local Government; from the State to the Citizen’.

It is the plans to scrap Seanad Eireann and cut the number of TDs that has attracted the greatest attention. Kenny states that these two measures wold save €150m over the term of a DΡil.

Mayo’s two senators, Paddy Burke (Fine Gael) and John Carty (Fianna FΡil) are very much at odds over the proposals.

“I certainly won’t be losing any sleep over this,” Senator John Carty told The Mayo News last night. “I think it is a red herring that has been thrown. I don’t agree with doing away with the Seanad but it does need reform.

”There is a perception among the public that the Seanad is very ineffective but that is not the reality. We have had legislation enacted and passed by the DΡil and vice versa. We often make very good amendments to legislation. Costs could be looked at as well but we sit for three days in Dublin and then we have constituency work, committee work, functions, so it is not as if we have a load of time to be twiddling our thumbs either.”

However Senator Paddy Burke (pictured), a long term associate of Enda Kenny’s, argues that the upper house is expendable as part of overall reform, even if it means he will be out of a job.

“The Senate needs reform - it is not working like it could or should be,” he told The Mayo News. “Enda’s strategy is to unclog the maze of bureaucracy that currently exists in the public service. Local areas are clogged up in bureaucracy - it is nearly impossible to get things done. If these plans unlock this maze, create a more efficient DΡil and local system of government and if that means abolishing the Senate, then I would welcome it, even if it does mean I would lose my job as a senator. I’ve been in politics a long time, it is a volatile world.”

While he argues that the Seanad plays an important role in terms of legislation, the oft heard charge that the Seanad is often little more than a talking shop is one Burke finds hard to dispute.

“I have no doubt that Seanad Eireann do a wonderful service in terms of scrutinising and amending bills. If that is taken over by the DΡil, then more due diligence will be needed. But I’m sure that is what Enda refers to in terms of expanding committee roles.

“What the Seanad does too though is it raises a lot of the same issues as the DΡil. Raising day to day issues is not entirely irrelevant but the same issues are raised in the DΡil by publicly elected people who are in a better position to speak.”

The proposals in relation to the Seanad would need to be put to a referendum. Enda Kenny is on record as stating that, were he to become Taoiseach, he would hold such a referendum within one year of taking office.

Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice