Retailers in need of therapy?

placeholder image

While shoppers were later coming out this Christmas, trade was pretty brisk in the county town.

Retailers in need of therapy?

While shoppers were later coming out this Christmas, trade was pretty brisk in the county town

Neill O'Neill

SHOPPING is to Castlebar what pubs and restaurants are to Westport, salmon fishing is to Ballina, religion is to Knock and horse racing to Ballinrobe. Simply, it is the flagship town in Mayo to visit for that purpose, and offers by far the best variety when it comes to retailing.

However, with the bleak economic outlook of late and the gloomy forecast for 2009, it was always going to be an anxious Christmas for store-owners in the county town. With that in mind, The Mayo News visited Castlebar on New Year’s Eve to see how the festive season passed.

“There were people queuing from the door to the corner of Market Square on Christmas Eve,” said Sean Ketterick of Ketterick’s Family Butchers, a statement that was taken with a pinch of salt until it was confirmed by an independent retailer across the street that the butcher brothers seemed to be having a bumper Christmas. Brian Ketterick added that the ‘Golden Mile’ (Hopkins Road) was busy all of Christmas week, but that the period of time during which people came out to do their Christmas shopping seemed shorter this year.

This was a common view among all retailers visited, as was the fact that while Christmas week was good in terms of turnover – and practically on par with other years – overall, Christmas takings were down on last year’s figures.

One supermarket retailer in Castlebar disclosed that no doomsday scenario manifested itself over Christmas, but that none of the multiples, discounters or other chain stores could claim to have had a bumper season. It is more likely, he contended, that each held its own customers, with figures in line with those of the year to date as expected – down.

Post-Christmas shoppers in Castlebar were on the streets for everybody to see last week. The car parks at Tesco/Dunnes were less than one third full at 10.30am on New Year’s Eve, but less than an hour later a queue had formed back to near the roundabout at McDonald’s to enter them. However, this was something traditionally witnessed for most of December in Castlebar, and one telling indicator from the anecdotal evidence that it was quieter than usual this Christmas was the fact that gardaí were not required on traffic duty on Hopkins Road until the day before Christmas Eve – weeks behind when they would usually appear there.

“There used to be queues of traffic on most approach roads to Castlebar,” Henry McGlade, proprietor of the Mega Music Store near Market Square, said, “but with Aldi and Tesco stores springing up in Claremorris, Ballinrobe and Westport of late, people are not bothering with the hassle of coming to Castlebar to do shopping anymore. As a result, lots of smaller stores are also feeling the knock-on effect of this.”  Henry added that he had no problem parking in the Castlebar Town Council-operated car park off Market Square this Christmas – which is something he has never experienced before.

SALES signs adorned most shop windows in Castlebar, as always for this time of year, but many promised discounts of up to 70 per cent, and some of these signs – including the one in Dunnes Stores – have been hanging for weeks now – something unheard of until the recession of 2008.

There were six till operators ringing groceries through the check-outs in Dunnes at 11.40am on New Year’s Eve, and the floor of the drapery section was filling up continuously. In Tesco’s minutes previously, there were ten check-outs open, but at half of these sat idle operators. One reliable in-store source told The Mayo News that the management of Tesco in Castlebar – able to remember the trends of the recession in the eighties – had been a little more cautious in their ordering of Christmas stock in 2008 than in previous years, as they felt that people would be more reserved in their spending with the global economy in crisis.

“People used to come in and buy items whether they needed them or not, but this is not the case now,” this person said. The source also disagreed with the theory that the growth of Tesco in Mayo was affecting their flagship Castlebar store, but said that overall Christmas was good – but down on recent years.

With the car park filling up outside, Tesco was beginning to buzz, while across town at SuperValu on New Antrim Street a similar trend was occurring, with the refurbished SuperValu supermarket and Penneys also coming alive.

SO, what of the theory that Main Street in Castlebar is now on borrowed time because of the flourishing ‘Castlebar Quarter Shopping’ on Hopkins Road – where customers are encouraged to ‘take centre stage’?

Not true, according to Peter Doherty of Leo Doherty Menswear, one of Castlebar’s most trusted and recognisable stores – which has been trading on Main Street since 1975.

“Main Street needs redevelopment and plans are at an advanced stage for this,” he said, “but there are still attractive stores on Main Street and the part of town where Dunnes/Tesco are located is only a two-minute walk from here. If they were in a green-field site two miles outside town it might be a whole different story, as it has been in other towns, but as it is Castlebar offers quality shopping right across the town.”

In a well-known shoe shop on Main Street, they were feeling no ill-effect of the curse of the ‘Golden Mile’, reporting that Christmas and the sales period to date have been very kind to them. They also feel that there are more than enough established stores on Main Street to keep the shoppers flocking in.

“In all the talk beforehand if we were offered what we ended up with we certainly would have taken it,” said one of their senior employees.

Leo Doherty’s was another outlet saying that while Christmas 2008 was good it was not as good as Christmas 2007.

“Christmas was not as bad as people predicted,” said Peter Doherty, “but the first two weeks of December were not as good as last year and while the two weeks before Christmas picked up and were about the same, this was not enough to bring the overall figure in line with what we would be used to.”

Regarding the post-Christmas period, Leo Doherty’s has been busy, a factor Peter attributes to an established business, and the fact that they did not go into sale mode before Christmas.

“Some stores who began sales before Christmas may now find that people are not coming in to view their range or avail of their offers because of familiarity with their stock,” he said.

Peter is predicting a difficult year in 2009 for many retailers, and he is not alone in his thinking. Where people are paying rents consistent with business levels and the economy of two or three years ago, many landlords may now find themselves looking for tenants where tenants do not exist. The closure of high street children’s clothing chain ‘Adams’ last week, following on from the collapse of Woolworths, is a warning that preventive action must be taken now.

Where people own and are not still paying a mortgage on their own business properties, they will find it much easier to survive, Peter feels, and high rents will have to be addressed, not just with landlords, but also further up the chain – by the landlords with banks – if the thousands of retailers across the country whose businesses are now in jeopardy are to be around to see next Christmas.

Related topics:
Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice