Refuse operators felt they were not acting illegally
DAILY UPDATE THE trial of a former Secretary of Mayo County Council, along with three waste disposal companies and their directors, who are being prosecuted for breaches of competition law heard
Refuse operators felt they were not acting illegally
Ann Healy
Galway
THE trial of a former Secretary of Mayo County Council, along with three waste disposal companies and their directors, who are being prosecuted for breaches of competition law heard yesterday (Thursday) on the third day of the trial that none of them felt they were doing anything illegal when they reached an agreement to form a company and submit a tender for the Mayo County Council loss-making refuse collection service put up for sale in 2005.
Mr Padraig Hughes, retired Secretary of Mayo Co. Council, denies six counts of aiding, abetting, counselling or procuring three waste disposal companies to commit an offence by entering into an agreement with each other, between August 24, 2005 and September 2, 2005, to prevent, restrict or distort competition by (a) sharing the market ; and (b) sharing the customer base, for the provision of waste collection services in Co. Mayo, contrary to Section 4(1) and 6 of the Competition Act 2002, being an offence to which Section 8(1) of the Act applies.
Company directors, Mr Stanley Bourke, of Bourke Waste Removal Limited, Clougher, Westport, Patrick McGrath and Declan McGrath of McGrath Industrial Waste Limited, Turlough, Castlebar, and Paul Gleeson of Wheeley Environmental Refuse Services Limited T/A Wers Waste, Weir Road, Tuam, Co. Galway, along with their three companies, all deny two charges each of entering into an agreement between August 24, 2005 and September 2, 2005, which had as its object the prevention, restriction or distortion of competition in the provision of domestic waste collection services in Mayo by: (a) sharing customers and, (b) sharing the market for the provision of such services.
Mr Paul McDermott, SC, prosecuting told the jury on the opening day of the trial last Tuesday that a Mr Michael Monaghan of Ballinrobe Waste Ltd., who operated a refuse collection service in the Ballinrobe and Claremorris areas, made a complaint to the Competition Authority which led to an investigation into the defendants and their companies.
It emerged that the charges before the court stemmed from the privatisation of waste collection services in Mayo which came into effect in January 2007. Mayo County Council along with Ballina, Castlebar and Westport Urban Councils had been operating their public refuse services for their respective 14,000 customers at a €1.2 million annual loss and the Councils decided jointly to put the collection service in both the urban (5,000 customers) and rural (9,000 customers) out to tender to see if private companies already operating in Co Mayo would take over the business.
Mr Monaghan told the trial yesterday that he received a tender document from Mayo County Council in August 2005 and knew on reading it that no one refuse operator could provide a service to all of Co Mayo and that existing operators would have to come together to submit a joint tender for the Council’s customer data base.
He said Mr Gleeson of Wers Waste, who was a ‘keen rival’ in his area, invited him to attend a meeting at the Dalton Inn Hotel in Claremorris on August 24, 2005. He said he met the other defendants, whom he did not know before this at the meeting, along with Mr Padraig Hughes, who chaired and mediated at the meeting.
“As we were all in the same business and Mr Gleeson and I were keen rivals, I suppose he (Hughes) was there to help us stop pulling the heads off each other,” Mr Monaghan said.
He said the main thrust of the meeting was to discuss the tender process and not to fix prices of wheelie bins and that Mr Hughes’ job was to try and get them to work together to submit a tender as the closing date was looming on September 2.
“If anyone thought it was against the law I don’t think any of us would have been there. Mr Hughes seemed to think there was nothing wrong with what we were doing because we were only submitting a tender.”
Mr Monaghan said he thought it “crazy” that the others were willing to make a joint €1.5 million bid for the Council’s customer data base when it was well known that the Council had been operating the business at a €1.25 million loss. “At the end of the day Mayo County Council got what the business was worth; they gave it away for nothing and that was what it was worth from day one,” he added.
He also expressed reservations about the legality of them coming together as trials of home heating oil companies were taking place at the time for alleged price fixing.
He pulled out of the deal at the third meeting, held on August 29 primarily because Mr. Gleeson had produced a ‘wish list’ at the first meeting proposing to divide up the customer base on geographical lines between the four companies, which would see Mr Monaghan losing his customers in Claremorris entirely to Gleeson’s company. “He (Gleeson) wanted to have all of Claremorris. Wers Waste would have liked to have it. He was going to give me nothing and he was looking for it from the day I started in business. He was looking for my bins from that day but so far he hasn’t succeeded,” Mr Monaghan said.
He said he also pulled out of the deal because the others wanted to see each others audited accounts for their existing businesses and because their proposed tender was ‘crazy’.
He agreed with defence teams for Stanley Bourke and the McGrath’s that they were respectable businessmen with impeccable reputations and that even Mr Gleeson, whom he kept referring to as his keen rival, would not have got involved in anything illegal. “They would have been out the door as fast as me,” if that was the case, Mr Monaghan said.
He also agreed that the men had never discussed sharing the customer base and they had discounted Gleeson’s ‘wish list’ too.
The remaining three company directors went ahead after Mr Monaghan withdrew and formed a limited company, which they called BMG Ltd (using their initials) on August 31, 2005. They tendered €1,287,000 for the Council’s business on September 2, 2005, while McGrath Industrial Waste Ltd submitted a ‘sister tender’ for one euro less at €1,286,999, in case the BMG tender was rejected for any reason.
Mr Monaghan submitted a separate tender on his own for the Council’s business in just the Ballinrobe and Claremorris areas. He told the trial that the Council subsequently sold their refuse business for what it was worth. The trial continues today Friday.