Prosecution concludes as defence teams prepare legal submissions
DAILY UPDATE THE prosecution case against the defendants concluded yesterday afternoon (Monday) and Mr Justice Liam McKechnie sent the jury away until 2pm today (Tuesday) when the four defence teams indicated they had legal submissions to make to the court before beginning their defence.
Prosecution concludes as defence teams prepare legal submissions
Ann Healy
Galway
THE prosecution case against the defendants concluded yesterday afternoon (Monday) and Mr Justice Liam McKechnie sent the jury away until 2pm today (Tuesday) when the four defence teams indicated they had legal submissions to make to the court before beginning their defence.
The fifth day of the trial heard evidence yesterday from two Competition Authority officers who had interviewed the defendants on various dates in July and August 2006.
In documents received from Mr Hughes the first officer, Mr. Michael Downey, said he found a document outlining an arrangement between the parties about the division of areas between them in Co Mayo. It contained a list of the defendants’ names alongside the areas their waste companies would service.
Mr Diarmuid McGuinness SC for Bourke Waste Ltd told Mr Downey that his client was not competing with any of the other defendants and already has his own customers in the Westport area and his only competitor up to that point had been Mayo Co. Council.
Mr Downey agreed with defence counsel that there were other waste disposal companies operating in Mayo at the time and they could continue to compete with the three defendant company’s before the court even if the BMG tender had been accepted.
Mr Eksteen Maritz, a South African barrister who took up employment with the Competition Authority in September 2005 and headed up this investigation said the Authority did not feel it necessary to employ the services of an economist to establish the customer base of each of the defendant company’s during the investigation. He said the investigation concentrated on trying to establish whether or not the defendants had entered into an agreement to divide up the county between them.
“We had to establish if an agreement had been reached between existing competitors in the market.” The trial continues this afternoon.