Paisley’s reconstruction
Speaker’s Corner I can’t remember exactly when or why I decided that DUP leader Ian Paisley was a bigot.
“Ian Paisley never held all the aces and he did not broker the peace deal on his own”
Speaker’s Corner
Denise Horan
I CAN’T remember when or why I decided Ian Paisley was a bigot. It was somewhere in that twilight period between childhood and adolescence, when I was old enough to have independent views but still young enough not to need concrete arguments to back them up.
I’m pretty sure it was before I learned what the word bigot meant, but not so sure if it was my own intuition or eavesdropping on adults that informed my childish decision to ‘hate’ him. Whatever my reasoning, when he appeared on the TV screen, the channel was changed.
Last week’s documentary by Tommie Gorman, ‘From Troublemaker to Peacemaker’, about Paisley’s apparent evolution from ‘never’ man to kindly grandfather type, rekindled those feelings. Watching footage from the fifties, sixties and seventies of the young reverend spitting vitriol about catholics and republicans temporarily stirred a hatred in me that I thought had passed. I guess there are some triggers we cannot control.
At the end of the documentary, I found it difficult to form an overall assessment – either of the programme or the man. Paisley has changed dramatically in recent years, that much was clear. Anyone who has paid the slightest bit of attention to events in Northern Ireland in recent times already knew that, and knew there were a number of hypotheses as to why this metamorphosis took place. But for the uninitiated viewer, none of these was explored in any detail in the documentary. Even for those with prior knowledge and opinions, little was added by way of persuasive argument to change or confirm any of them.
The three most popular hypotheses about Paisley’s transformation are that: (a) his ill-health a couple of years ago was the turning point, making him realise that he had a second chance to be the one who did the impossible in his home province, by getting all sides working together; (b) old age was his mellower, making him less entrenched in his views and more tolerant of others’; (c) he was forced through the reversal in the DUP’s fortunes, which made them the figureheads of unionism and the largest party in the North, to accept the responsibilities that go with power.
For me, there was no Damascene conversion. I believe it was a combination of all three factors that led to Paisley’s reconstruction, with a measure of luck thrown in. (I also believe that too much emphasis is placed on Paisley’s role in the current status of Northern Ireland, to the exclusion of the efforts of many unionist leaders that went before and the equally crucial roles of many nationalist figures past and present. Not to mention Albert Reynolds and Bertie Ahern, John Major and Tony Blair. Paisley never held all the aces and he did not broker the peace deal on his own. So let us guard against the kind of revisionism that makes a virtue out of longevity and applauds a little too loudly the public setting aside – after a lifetime – of stubbornness, pig-headedness and bigotry.)
Of the three factors that fed into the Paisley conversion, the most interesting is his acceptance of responsibility with power. The two should always go hand in hand, but alas they don’t. Paisley is to be lauded for his leadership in this regard. When the DUP got into the ascendancy, he could have attempted the same uncompromising approach to republicans that had, for decades, made him a walking explanation of the term ‘polarising figure’. Realising people on all sides were now looking to him, and realising that all of those people, regardless of persuasion, coveted peace equally, he softened – and in so doing became a real leader.
The great unanswered question at the end of last week’s documentary, however, was: does he regret not adopting a conciliatory approach years ago? It would have been instructive for others all over Ireland, whose parties are currently in the minority at whatever level of politics they operate, to know if he has regrets about being so bullish and thick when there was no prospect of him being in power.