Owner contests charge after driver seriously injured in collision with horse
A man charged with a breach of the Control of Horses Act after his horse collided with a car, has contested the charge
Legal argument ensues about the nature of the charge after collision near Bangor-Erris
A Bangor-Erris man charged with a breach of the Control of Horses Act after his horse collided with a car, has contested the charge.
The accident left the driver of the car with serious injuries and the horse had to be put down.
George Sweeney of Briska, Bangor Erris appeared before Belmullet District Court on Wednesday last charged with being ‘in charge or control of a horse’ and who ‘wilfully or recklessly permitted’ the horse to pose a danger to a person, arising from the incident.
The court heard from Westport man Paddy McGuire who was driving on the Ballycroy to Bangor-Erris road on October 28, 2014 when, at approximately 11pm, he said a horse ran across the road in front of him and collided with his car.
He said he was knocked out and spent two weeks in hospital. His injuries included a ‘cracked skull’, permanent damage to his hearing, a restriction in his ability to walk and broken bones in his face.
Straying
Ballycroy man Michael Grealis said he was driving in the opposite direction and saw Mr McGuire’s car collide with the horse. He said he knew to slow down on that stretch of road as he said he had seen a horse stray onto the road at that particular stretch of the N59 in the days before the accident.
Michael Bohan, defence solicitor, asked Mr Grealis was there ‘large parts’ of land along that road unfenced. Mr Grealis agreed and also said the sheep, cattle and deer had been known to stray onto the road.
Michael Cusack from Fahy, Westport gave evidence of selling this horse and another horse to Mr Sweeney for €50 a month before the accident. The horse had just been microchipped before the sale.
Garda Amanda Cunningham said she received a call to attend the accident. She said Mr McGuire was ‘quite injured’ and she spoke with him to keep him conscious. She said the horse was in a drain 100 metres away and was ‘badly injured’. A vet was contacted who had to put down the horse. The vet gave the horse’s microchip number to Garda Cunningham and the number was traced to Mr Sweeney.
Garda Cunningham said Mr Sweeney paid the €200 bill for the call out for the vet on the night. She said Mr Sweeney kept this horse and another on commonage at the back of his house.
Mr Bohan argued that the Section 45.1 charge of wilfully or recklessly permitting the horse was a stronger charge than Section 45.2 which states wilfully or recklessly causes a horse to pose a danger to a person under the Control of Horses Act 1996.
Garda Cunningham said the charge before the court was the charge directed by the Director of Public Prosecutions.
Commonage
Mr Bohan said Mr Sweeney accepts it was his horse but argued about the nature of the charge.
He spoke as to what is considered reckless and argued that the same level of responsibility does not apply to the owner of animal on unfenced land, such as commonage.
He also said that the charge of ‘permitting’ the horse to pose a danger was a much stronger definition than the charge of ‘causes’ the horse to pose a danger.
He argued Mr Sweeney did not herd the horse onto the road with the intention of causing injury and that there was no intent to cause injury. He said this is what the charge of ‘permitting’ implies.
Inspector Tom Calvey (prosecuting) said it is similar to driving cases where a person may not intent to injure another but if they were reckless in their driving, they were responsible and that the same principles applied here.
“Mr Sweeney made no effort to control his horse … and a man got injured as a result of his actions,” said Inspector Calvey. He said the ‘onus’ was on George Sweeney to enclose the horse and make sure it would not wander and that by not doing so, he was ‘reckless’.
Judge Alan Mitchell said that Mr Bohan’s legal argument could be a very important point for such prosecutions in future and adjourned the case to allow both the defence and prosecutions to make written submissions on the legal arguments raised by Mr Bohan.
The case was adjourned to October 12, at which stage a date will be fixed for the decision.