OPINION: Northwest’s rail needs downplayed again


Dublin’s depressingly predictable response to the All Island Strategic Rail Review
The recent publication of the All Island Strategic Rail Review (AISRR) prompted stinging, if very predictable, criticisms by a number of commentators in the Dublin-based print media.
The Irish Times led the charge with withering put downs by their economics columnist, Professor John Fitzgerald (“Draft rail strategy is fun for trainspotters but is full of fantasy”), and by Michael McDowell, former leader of the PDs (“Nostalgic fantasies about rail won’t change reality that we need roads”).
Worse, the Taoiseach, Leo Varadkar, had led off by welcoming the AISRR as representing the best case he had seen for building more roads.
But no funds for improving the N17, of course.
The criticisms had two focal points. First, a modern east-coast higher-speed rail system is far too expensive. Second, rail is unsuitable for ‘rural’ Ireland; let them drive cars and take the bus.
The tone of arrogant omniscience that colours such views is what we have come to expect. It displays a refusal to consider that development challenges in the North and West region are very different from the problems of the swollen population agglomeration of the greater Dublin area that dominate government thinking (and Dáil seats) and kills whatever hope we have of forward-looking and transformative regional strategy.
The airing of Dublin-based experts’ views on modernising the rail system, however unpalatable, offers an opportunity to discuss implications far wider than the future of the island rail network. The criticisms shine an unexpected light on linkages to a host of other strategic development choices that the current and past governments have been unable or unwilling to address effectively over past decades.
Broader view
Let’s step back from Dublin carping and take a broader view on what is going on here. The real problem starts not with the AISRR, but with the deeply flawed national development strategy, Project Ireland 2040.
If there is fantasy in the air, it originates there. A strategy that peddles vague and unrealistic visions of ‘rural’ prosperity yet continues to facilitate further unsustainable enlargement of the Dublin-centred economy. A strategy that generates even more scattering of the labour force over a greater Dublin area that is poorly served by housing, road and rail transport infrastructure and whose airport car park is always full. A strategy that created a diffused city whose present and future mass transport needs are impossible to tackle by rail at reasonable cost.
Professor Fitzgerald criticised the absence of credible cost-benefit analysis in the AISRR to justify value for money from investment in rail and asserts that an outcome where costs are balanced by benefits is simply not good enough. He believes that costs are always underestimated and benefits overestimated.
However, close reading of the AISRR analysis suggests that its authors did exactly the opposite. They appear to have little interest in restoring economic dynamism to lagging regions like the Northwest. Benefits slightly less than costs are the most that they conceded, and this drove their rejection of the complete restoration of the Western Rail Corridor linking Limerick to Sligo. A bizarre decision since the line from Athenry to Claremorris was recommended for restoration but the final 74km of track from Claremorris to Collooney/Sligo was rejected. This is almost like building a bridge half way across a river. On limited use!
Industries in the Northwest, already clamouring for access to rail transport, will be unable to use the rail line for moving raw materials and finished products south to Waterford and Foynes, reducing their carbon footprint, saving time, money and reducing single track delays on the Westport and Sligo lines to Dublin.
Professor Fitzgerald highlights the existing availability of motorways, but appears either unaware of, or indifferent to, their almost complete absence from the Northwest! He believes that most road transport (including HGVs) will be decarbonised by 2040, so why bother with trains?
Brushing aside the objective of more balanced growth on the island, he fails to see that restoration and expansion of rail would play an important role in producing a more equitable and efficient platform for national growth in an era when climate change policies are mandatory.
The rest of the EU is already moving swiftly in that direction. The US, which implemented Professor Fitzgerald’s vision of personalised road transport, with buses for the poor who cannot afford automobiles, moved in a different direction and is the major driver of global warming.
Dysfunctional
Mr McDowell’s critique is less compelling. Perhaps he just read the government press release rather than the report, since he appeared not to realise that Arup carried out a cost-benefit analysis of selected rail proposals and details are available on the government website.
His only valid point concerned the increasing dysfunctionality of Irish government policymaking where clear, transparent and democratic processes have become subverted by a chaotic jungle of uncooperative government departments hiding in their silos (who exactly is in charge of Irish transport policy?); public agencies promoting their own narrow interests (witness Dublin Port’s anti-rail stance); and hiring private consultancy firms (EY, Arup) to do jobs that would be better handled more directly by experts within the public sector. So, Mr McDowell got one thing right!
John Bradley is a former ESRI professor and has published on the island economy of Ireland, EU development policy, industrial strategy and economic modelling.