OPINION: Hard questions for NGOs after referenda results


That old political adage linking governments, banana skins and referendums proved right once more, and the panicked footsteps we heard were the politicians deserting the ship as fast as they could. There always has to be a fall guy at such times, and when the music stopped, it was Equality Minister Roderic O’Gorman who found himself without a chair.
Then came the blame game. The governing trio blamed each other, and Ms Bacik and Mary Lou came centre stage to make the risible claim that, while they had backed the proposals, they had disagreed with the measures all along.
How the massed ranks of our political masters, of every shade and hue (bar Aontu) could have made such a monumental dog’s dinner of the referendums will call for deep self-analysis. That they treated the public as half wits, ready to buy any pig in a poke, is beyond question. But how the practitioners of the political trade, where the first essential is to be tuned into the thinking of the electorate, could be so out of touch with public opinion is beyond explicable.
The defeat of the referendum was the most comprehensive such rejection in the history of the State, but the Government can hardly have been surprised. The proposed changes were confusing, the explanations were unconvincing, spokesmen floundered when put under pressure, the campaign was leaden, the timing was cynical. The only crumb of comfort for the Government was that virtually all the opposition parties had followed the piper, and found themselves equally marooned on the wrong side of the river. That, and the reality that its effect on the coming elections will be short lived.
A further question raised was the influence, or otherwise, of the NGOs (non governmental organisations), of which the country is awash, and which solidly backed the referendum campaign. These NGOs are, by and large, funded by the State, and yet purport to represent the views of various cohorts of citizens in lobbying against the Government. The question now is how truly representative can they claim to be, given that their advocacy of a ‘Yes’ vote was so roundly rejected by the thousands whose interests they claim to speak for.
NGOs depend on the Government for their funding; their reluctance to bite the hand that feeds them is understandable. And in case any might have doubts, Minister O’Gorman reminded them that they would have to explain themselves if they were found calling for a rejection. All duly obliged; the risk of being labelled as government lackeys was obviously worth taking.
But alas, the electorate thought otherwise. In spite of the unstinted advocacy of the National Women’s Council, Oxfam, the Childrens Rights’ Alliance, Family Resource Centres, the Union of Students, and a plethora of similarly cushioned advocacy groups, the people they represent rejected their advice. Eight of the main NGO advocates of the referendum campaign received an exchequer income of €40 million in funding last year, a revelation that must now cast doubts about what interests were being represented and how little real independence these organisations really have.
In addition, the referendum backers included the Irish Congress of Trade Unions, which claims to represent over half a million members but which, on this occasion, was singing from a different hymn sheet than its members.
The cost of the referendum was €23 million. And while all of this prodigal spending was being written off as incidental expenses, RTÉ was reporting the scandal of 200 wretches living in tents, on the main street of the capital, in the most squalid, filthy, repulsive conditions, without running water or sanitation. Prone to all sorts of disease and malnutrition, with doorsteps as latrines, these were the asylum seekers for whom the authorities choose to look the other way.