On being an expert


SONIA KELLY “Suddenly people without any specific training become rulers of a country and ministers are appointed randomly”
However, from my own experience and observation anyone can become a self-styled expert. All that’s necessary is to proclaim expertise in the chosen subject and few, if any, will have the temerity to challenge the statement.
Anyone, for instance, can set up as a herbalist. It’s easy to get a reference book and a supplier. Psychics are another class of people who operate without official proof of expertise. Their spurious claims have recently been demonstrated during the search for missing bodies, when knowledge has been claimed as to their whereabouts, which in various cases drew complete blanks.
Another recent ploy in the psychic realm is the announcement that hyperactive children are actually the latest step in evolution, being endowed with a sixth sense and apparently able to see and converse with the dead. They are called ‘Indigo’ children and an ‘expert’ in this field has verified that their brain waves correspond to certain scientific monitoring. As I have a book myself called ‘The Boy who Saw True’ about a boy in Victorian times who, not only communicated with the departed, but who also saw and spoke with gnomes (in their red caps) it doesn’t seem like a very new development.
Astrology also offers an open invitation to experts. Almost anything can be accredited to the position of the planets – both currently and at the time of one’s birth. We know that the ancient experts waxed powerful by predicting their movements and relating them to the seasons, but today’s savants have become even more esoteric and, of course, harder to take issue with. The planets determine what type of personality we have, depending on their position when we were born, but also depending on whether they were in the ascendancy, or governed by another one that was. When I say that the moon comes into it, too, and affects our libido, or life force, known as the ‘morphogenic field’, you will get a glimpse of what I mean. A fraction of this knowledge would be enough for anyone to claim expertise – and this is, indeed, just what the various ubiquitous fortune-tellers in our society do.
But it’s not that anyone can set up as an expert – any subject will do to pontificate on co-incidence, for example. There is a book about this by an Indian philosopher. (And here, again, the very fact of propounding a theory gives one authenticity as a philosopher). Coincidences, he states, are the preconceived ploys of fate to determine our lives, and they happen at significant moments. But, if you think, coincidences happen all the time and it’s up to oneself whether to exploit any one, or not. Carpe diem, or seize the moment, seems more apt. However, the author’s version is called ‘Synchronicity’, which shows the importance of giving one’s fantasy a name – like ‘Indigo’ children.
One group of experts that is really questionable would be politicians. Suddenly people without any specific training become rulers of a country and ministers are appointed randomly to deal with sectors like sport, say, or the environment without having any previous experience. Wouldn’t you think that government was one area where real experts were needed!
Perhaps their lack of expertise in running things is what has given rise to the age of counselling – a period when some expert is always on hand to comfort and advise one in times of trouble. Like the one I happened across after a rather traumatic incident concerning a cat. “You should write to your pet,” was the advice, “and explain your feelings to it.” I mean… the cat left no address!
Not forgetting, of course, that I was a counsellor myself in the days when I ran the Health Centre. That is how I know that ‘expert’ knowledge is never questioned.