No wigs on the green at last Kenny court


Retiring judge Harvey Kenny’s robust style and ‘whirlwind’ impact on the Western Circuit Court was outlined by a gallery of speakers in Castlebar courthouse on Wednesday morning.
Judge Harvey Kenny is pictured with members of the legal profession and former county registar Patsy Murphy on the steps of the Courthouse in Castlebar after his retirement from the Western Circuit last week.


“BEFORE I start to speak, I have something important to say.” Groucho Marx was the inspiration for barrister John Jordan’s introduction to his paean to retiring Circuit Court Judge Harvey Kenny in Castlebar courthouse on Wednesday morning last.
In one tribute after the other, Harvey Kenny’s robust style and ‘whirlwind’ impact on the Western Circuit Court over a decade from 1995 was outlined by a gallery of speakers.
Effectively, Judge Kenny deleted the word ‘adjournment’ from the western circuit’s lexicon. John Jordan recalled one of his first encounter’s with the judge.
“I recall one of my first encounter’s with Judge Kenny. I was attending Swinford Circuit Court with 13 briefs in my bag – and they all knew the road to Swinford and back – and by the time we finished at 10.40 that night they were all dealt with,” observed Jordan, encapsulating Judge Kenny’s phenomenal work rate.
The other mark he left was ‘physical’ in nature.
“Among the physical legacy you left on the western circuit is this extraordinarily fine building. We had worked in a dark, grim obsolete building for years until you singlehandedly orchestrated [its refurbishment] and lobbied anybody who might have some influence,” continued John Jordan.
Mr Jordan also drily recalled how a drop from the roof of Clifden courthouse – which was particularly Dickenisan – used to splatter on the formica topped table he sat at and wash over his spectacles. Furthermore, down near the holding cells there were spades and buckets and a ‘Danger Road Up’ sign.
“I suspect if it wasn’t for your good work that road sign might still be there,” quipped Jordan.
Speaking then of Judge Kenny’s judicial style, he said: “The memory of litigants and lawyers that came before you is a memory of a straight-talking, no nonsense judge. In order to compel people to see sense and accept an impartial opinion it is often necessary to be robust.”
Then, wishing Judge Kenny a long and happy retirement, Mr Jordan recalled a drole vignette from another senior colleague on his retirement some time ago.
“First you forget faces. Then you forget names. Then you forget to zip up your fly, Then you forget to unzip your fly.”
Praise
REPRESENTING the Mayo Bar Association, Mr Dermot Hewson also praised the judge for his proactive role in courthouse renovations throughout Mayo.
He also remarked: “It was very clear when you came your capacity for work was unlimited and no list was too long for you. One thing that struck me about that ‘robust style’ was that particularly difficult cases were settled due to your great knowledge of the law.”
On behalf of the Court Services, Brendan McDonnell recalled Judge Kenny’s arrival in Loughrea in 1995. He noted that those with previous acquaintanceship predicted there was ‘a whirlwind coming’.
“At the time the waiting lists were two years long, they soon were cut back to two months,” said McDonnell, “I would rate Castlebar one of the best courthouses in the country.”
Addressing the court on behalf of the Garda Síochána, Superintendent Willie Keaveney, thanked Judge Kenny for his ‘dedication to law enforcement in County Mayo’.
“You have had some serious cases before you and Mayo is now a safer place because of you. Since 1995, your no nonsense approach has worked well. There is nothing more demoralising that adjournments, I thank you for your courtesy towards gardaí and the impartiality you showed defendants.”
To much laughter, County Registrar, Mr Fintan Murphy cited one of ‘the Harvey rules’: “Adjournments will be granted on the production of a death certificate!”
Judge Harvey Kenny responds
RESPONDING that he was ‘humbled’ by the litany of tributes, Judge Kenny recalled that retired registrar Mr Patsy Murphy, his staff, the gardaí and legal professionals were working in poor accommodation back then.
He also urged for review and reform of a system that remains slow-moving and inefficient.
“There is a need for the system to be reviewed so that it doesn’t take four to five weeks of trial time. The system must be overhauled, so time is not wasted.”
He recollected that during renovations, after his arrival, criminal trials were moved to Westport, where the adjacent Castlecourt Hotel was used as consultation rooms.
“One American woman wrote to me to say how appalled she was to see a man in chains being brought through the restaurant while she was having breakfast.”
Judge Kenny continued: “My [court] Crier, John, once made the remark that you’d be a long time in Dublin before you’d get a case like you get in Mayo. I only have to think of that famous [Achill] rooster, it still plagues me.”
He was referring to a recent TG4 programme about the legendary 1997 Achill rooster case.