NATURE: Could non-native rainbow trout help save our lake angling?

DWINDLING POPULATION With wild brown trout such as this beauty in short supply, rainbow trout could help save our worldwide angling reputation.placeholder image
DWINDLING POPULATION With wild brown trout such as this beauty in short supply, rainbow trout could help save our worldwide angling reputation.

For the majority of trout anglers, 2023 will be remembered for one thing only – we have seen perhaps the poorest catch returns in the history of the State.

While some of the bigger loughs, such as Mask and Corrib, have produced the goods occasionally, others have been consistently poor. Many who have spent decades afloat in search of the fish for which the wild fisheries of the west earned a worldwide reputation are troubled about the continued downward spiral of water quality and angling reward.

Hardworking clubs and determined individuals have invested hugely in trying to maintain a population of fish that is not only viable, but that is also a credit to the country.

Still the decline persists.

Some consider part of the problem to be an entrenched way of thinking on the part of Inland Fisheries Ireland. We cannot take issue with the visible face of IFI. For the most part, those whose feet are on the ground are in it for the love of the job. Generous men and women, they are free with their knowledge and experience while glad of the privileged outdoor office they enjoy.

The difficulty lies with legislation and ideas that are no longer fit for purpose. A catchphrase often bandied about is ‘Manage the catchment (including the rivers and streams that feed the great lakes) and leave the fish alone’.

There is no question that this must be best practice. If our waterways were running clean and clear as they were even half a century ago, then fish stocks would be much healthier than they currently are.

But I challenge you to find a clean stream. Why, for the most part, the tiny brooks and rivulets that constitute trout nurseries are excavated to ridiculous depths or else choked with weed and sediment. We face the unfortunate fact that for the majority of these small streams there is no way back. They are gone. Ruined. Destroyed.

Those streams were the life of the lakes. Without them there can be no proper recruitment of juvenile trout. Trout hatcheries might provide a temporary solution, where juvenile fish are reared in a protected environment and used to stock the lakes artificially.

There are difficulties even there, in that it becomes man who plays matchmaker rather than nature. The advantage of natural selection is then abandoned. Intensive production of any living creature also brings problems in the form of disease, although modern technology and medication can minimise the risk. All of this should be unnecessary.

We could learn something from one of Scotland’s premier trout fishing destinations, the Lake of Menteith.

By Irish standards, Menteith, at 700 acres, is just a small body of water. By comparison, Lough Carra covers some 4,000 acres, Mask spans 22,000 and Corrib covers a vast 42,000 acres.

But here is where it gets interesting. The comparatively diminutive Lake of Menteith attracts in the region of 15,000 anglers per year. One recent report had successful anglers boating up to 25 trout averaging over two pounds in weight in a single day.

So what is it that makes such a small lake so popular? It is the quality of the fish within.

This was originally a wild brown trout lake, as are the Great Lakes of the west of Ireland. However, various pressures led to a decision being made to stock the lake, not with indigenous brown trout, but with non-native non-fertile rainbow trout for people to catch.

There is no doubting the success of this venture. The water is rich and provides plenty of insect and invertebrate food to support a dense population of trout. Extra fish are stocked through the season at a rate of about a thousand a week. A lot of these are captured and taken for the table not long after stocking, but many survive to grow large. The largest rainbow trout recorded from this venue weighed an impressive 21 pounds, while the average weight of fish caught in a recent competition was just shy of three pounds, with competing anglers boating an average of six fish each.

Recent competitions on the beleaguered Lough Carra have yielded very little.

The introduction of rainbow trout is also a reversible solution. If the decision were ever made to revert to a brown-trout-only fishery, it would be a simple matter to cease the stocking of the infertile rainbow trout. Within two or three years nobody would ever know they had been there at all.

Could stocking our large wild trout fisheries with sterile rainbow trout provide a temporary lifeline until the powers that be finally get to work? The waters are rich, the potential enormous.

Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice