McHale Park development in doubt

Leave it to Mr O’Brienplaceholder image
Leave it to Mr O’Brien

Stormy Castlebar Town Council meeting sees councillors vote in favour of revoking planning permission for GAA stadium

McHale Park development in doubt

THE media tower and adjoining toilets at the re-developed McHale Park in Castlebar may have to be demolished after a majority of Castlebar Town councillors voted to revoke planning permission granted to the Mayo County GAA Board for the development.

This comes after it has emerged in recent weeks that the media tower doesn’t conform to what was sought in the planning application and at a tension packed meeting of the Town Council last Thursday night, the members voted 6-3 in favour of Cllr Frank Durcan’s motion to revoke the planning permission.

The meeting, held at Aras an Chontae, was attended by close to 40 residents of McHale Road.

The success of the motion led Town Manager Seamus Granahan to state he would be getting legal advice after he questioned whether the councillors could legally revoke the permission for the tower. The tower is part of a €15m re-development at the venue.

However, speaking after the meeting Mayor Michael Kilcoyne, was confident that the motion will develop successfully.

“I am satisfied that we are on a firm footing,” he told The Mayo News. “We, the councillors who have supported the residents, will consider further action if we’re refused. Discussions have to take place between the County Board and the residents and a solution has to be arrived at. The solution that will be arrived at won’t involve the current broadcasting box. That will have to go. It is an ugly sight, like something you would see in Long Kesh.”

Cllr Kilcoyne also told the meeting that he felt this could have been avoided had the County Board ‘shown respect’ to the residents.

“The County Board have nobody to blame but themselves,” said Councillor Kilcoyne. “They are like the cowboy builders we talk about at meetings all the time - get permission for one thing and build something else.”

The motion was proposed by Cllr Frank Durcan who also argued that there was no planning permission for toilets adjoining the media tower.

Cllr Durcan, a valuer by profession, also stated that the prices of the houses on McHale Road directly opposite the tower had gone down in value.

The four Fine Gael councillors - Cllrs Ger Deere, Brendan Henaghan, Noreen Heston and Eugene McCormack - informed the meeting they had met with the County Board’s architects, David O’Malley & Co, and it initially appeared they were going to vote en masse against the motion.

However Councillor Brendan Henaghan broke ranks and voted in favour of the motion.

Labour’s Harry Barrett, Fianna Fail’s Blackie Gavin and Sinn Féin’s Therese Ruane also voted for the motion, together with the proposer and seconder - Cllr Durcan and Mayor Kilcoyne.

A notice of motion was also served by Cllr Frank Durcan and a special meeting was convened to direct the Town Manager to refuse the retention planning permission sought in recent weeks for the alterations.

That meeting will take place on September 21 at a venue to be confirmed.

After the vote was taken Ms Maura Flynn spoke on behalf of the McHale Road residents. She stated that the residents were not against the re-development of McHale Park, but against the nature of the building of the tower, as well as the visual impact.

“We wanted something nice built. We are not against the development. But when we saw what was going up we knew something was wrong. You do not build something and then apply for planning permission. That’s what drives us mad. We have all built extensions to our houses. We applied for planning permission and conformed with the law. Let the County Board do the same.”

Speaking on Friday County Board Chairman James Waldron said they were going to wait for the outcome of their application for planning retention. That application is on public viewing for a five week period.

“There is a process there in place and we’ll be leaving it up to the planning people. I don’t think it can be sorted by the councillors, it is a matter for the planners. I wouldn’t be worried because there is a process there. We’ve left everything to the design team and they’ve made the necessary changes.”

What Castlebar Town Council said

The motion

Under Section 44 of the Planning and Development Act of 2000, we propose to revoke planning permission granted to the Mayo County GAA Board regarding the construction of the TV Tower and toilets facing onto McHale Road being contrary to the Castlebar Development Plan as they do not have planning permission and they would demolish, if not devalue, the property prices of houses on McHale Road. Submitted by Cllr Frank Durcan

FOR the motion

Cllr Frank Durcan (who proposed the motion)

“The tower is one metre higher and three metres wider than it should be. It is a deceitful and incomplete planning application. It is ridiculous that this would happen in this day and age.”

Mayor Michael Kilcoyne (who seconded the motion)

“They built something else than what they applied for, like the cowboy builders we talk about at meetings all the time. Get permission for one thing and build something else.”

Cllr Brendan Henaghan

“The way the County Board have gone about their business leaves a lot to be desired.

If every development in the town was like this there would be total chaos.”

Cllr Therese Ruane

“There is an obvious breach of planning here but I have to admit I am unsure about what to do.

I have to say that looking at the tower it looks like the military tower in Crossmaglen.”

Cllr Blackie Gavin

”I got a phone call from David O’Malley’s office to look at the plans. I refused to go. It is a fine stadium but the media tower is not something we’re very proud of.”

Cllr Harry Barrett

“This is the first time in a long time that public representatives have stood for the people. We have planning laws. I have to act when people make a strong case.”

AGAINST the motion

Cllr Noreen Heston

“I would encourage communication and for all sides to come around the table. I’m saddened. We didn’t need this action. The way to resolve this was through dialogue.”

Cllr Eugene McCormack

“The County Board made the application in good faith. They were then told by RTÉ that the tower was not adequate for their needs. They didn’t seek retention then which is the crux.”

Cllr Ger Deere

“We can look to get headlines if we want but this has to be resolved through dialogue. I can’t condone what has been done by the County Board but I am not sure this proposal will get things resolved.”

Related topics:
Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice