MCC secretary pleads not guilty

Trial over alleged Mayo waste industry ‘carve up’ expected to go into next weekplaceholder image
Trial over alleged Mayo waste industry ‘carve up’ expected to go into next week

DAILY UPDATE  Trial over alleged Mayo waste industry ‘carve up’ expected to go into next week

Former Mayo County Secretary pleads not guilty to breaches of competition law

PLEADING NOT GUILTY Former County Secretary, Padraic Hughes

Ann Healy

Galway

THE trial of a former Secretary of Mayo County Council (MCC) charged with aiding and abetting the directors of three waste disposal companies in Mayo and Galway who are accused of breaches of competition law by attempting to ‘carve up’ the waste disposal business in C. Mayo between them in 2005, began before the Central Criminal Court sitting in Galway yesterday (Tuesday).

Mr Hughes, who retired as Secretary of MCCin 2000, denies three counts of aiding, abetting, counselling or procuring three waste disposal companies to commit an offence by entering into an agreement with each other over a nine-day period, between August 24, 2005 and September 2, 2005, to prevent, restrict or distort competition by sharing the market for the provision of waste collection services in Co Mayo, contrary to Section 4(1) and 6 of the Competition Act 2002, being an offence to which Section 8(1) of the Act applies.

He denies three further charges of aiding, abetting, counselling or procuring the three companies to enter into an agreement with each other between the same dates to share customers in Co Mayo thus preventing competition.

Company directors, Mr Stanley Bourke, of Bourke Waste Removal Limited, Clougher, Westport, Patrick McGrath and Declan McGrath of McGrath Industrial Waste Limited, Turlough, Castlebar, and Paul Gleeson of Wheeley Environmental Refuse Services Limited T/A Wers Waste, Weir Road, Tuam, Co Galway, all deny two charges each of entering into an agreement between August 24, 2005 and September 2, 2005, which had as its object the prevention, restriction or distortion of competition in the provision of domestic waste collection services in Mayo by: (a) sharing customers and, (b) sharing the market for the provision of such services. The three companies also deny two similar charges each.

The trial heard yesterday that the eight defendants were prosecuted for breaches of competition law when the director of another waste disposal company, Mr Michael Monaghan of Monaghan Waste Ltd, Ballinrobe, made a complaint to the Competition Authority in 2006.

It emerged that the charges before the court stemmed from the privatisation of waste collection services in Mayo which came into effect in January 2007.  MCC along with Ballina, Castlebar and Westport Urban Councils had been operating their public refuse services for their respective 14,000 customers at a loss and it was decided to put the collection service in both the urban (5,000 customers) and rural (9,000 customers) out to tender to see if private companies would take over the loss-making business from the Council.

Mr Paul McDermott SC, prosecuting told the jury of seven men and five women that the directors of the three companies, who had been rivals in the waste disposal business up to this, decided to meet on hearing of the Council’s intention to privatise refuse collection in Co. Mayo and they formed a consortium which they called BGM Ltd. (after its directors, Mr. Bourke, Gleeson and McGrath).

Mr Hughes, he said, was the facilitator or mediator between the once rival companies.

“He was brought in to assist in the making of this agreement.  Because of his former knowledge with his experience in County Council matters in his former employment he helped them put together a tender for MCC.  He facilitated and brokered the ultimate agreement made between the company directors,” Mr. McDermott said.

The Council received twenty ‘expressions of interest’ from companies interested in tendering for the business.  They included submissions from the three companies and also from Mr Monaghan of Ballinrobe Waste Ltd.  Of these, fourteen companies were invited to submit tenders by the September 2, 2005 deadline.

Mr McDermott said that from August 24, 2005 and up to the deadline, the defendants all met at the D’Alton Inn, Claremorris on a number of occasions to broker an agreement between themselves.  He said Mr. Monaghan attended the meetings.

Those attending the meetings discussed the submission of a joint tender to MCC to take over its refuse collection service but they went beyond that, he said, at a meeting on August 24, 2005, when they decided to divide and carve up - along geographical lines - the sharing of customers and market share among themselves in Mayo.

Each company agreed not to poach customers from the other company’s designated areas and in one instance, he said, the McGrath’s agreed to relinquish customers they had had in the Ballinrobe area to Mr. Monaghan’s company.

Mr McDermott said the decision to submit a joint tender from BMG Ltd was to buy the Council’s waste disposal business but its secondary objective was to reorganise the refuse collection market in Co Mayo and to divide that market and the customer base between the various companies.  In doing so they looked to confine and limit competition in the waste disposal business in Co Mayo.

“By doing so, they could discourage other people from coming into the market and set the price so that competition could be discouraged and restricted.  There was to be no trespassing by one operator on the other and each operator would retain his customers under the new agreement while each operator would continue to operate individually,” he explained.

Mr McDermott said the “horse trading” began in earnest on August 29, 2005 but Mr Monaghan expressed reservations about the proposed consortium and he withdrew from the negotiations on August 30.  The new company or consortium of BGM Ltd. was created the following day, on August 31, 2005.  It submitted a tender to Mayo Co. Council for €1,287,000 on September 2, 2005, while McGrath Industrial Waste Ltd. submitted a “sister tender” of one euro less at €1,286,999.

Mr McDermott said this ‘sister tender’ was submitted by McGrath's in case the BGM tender was unsuccessful.

Former MCC Director of Services, Mr Raymond Norton told the trial Mr Hughes rang him requesting a meeting and he met him in the presence of Mr. Sean Smith at the Council offices in late August 2005.  He said Mr Hughes wanted to know if the Council would accept a tender from a new company called BGM Ltd and would it be in order to submit a tender on the company’s behalf.

Mr Norton said he told Mr. Hughes the company would have to apply for a waste collection permit in order to collect waste in Co Mayo.  He told him he didn’t envisage any problems with that as the directors of the new consortium already had licences for their existing companies.

Mr Norton said Mr Hughes also asked him if it would be in order for McGrath to submit another tender in case BGM ran into difficulties and he told him he had no comment to make on that but that anyone who wanted to submit a tender could do so.

Mr Norton said the Council received five tenders by September 2, 2005, including one from BGM, one from McGrath’s and one from Ballinrobe Waste Ltd.

He said the Council had intended to ‘exit’ the refuse service by January 2006 but protracted labour disputes prevented it from doing so until January, 2007.

He said he met with BMG on a number of occasions in the interim to let them know what was happening and how soon the Council would be able to make a decision on the tender and while a draft agreement was produced it was never completed, Mr. Norton said.

The trial continues today and is expected to go into next week.

* The maximum penalties on conviction under the 2002 Competition Act are five years in prison and/or a fine of either €4 million or 10% of the pre-tax turnover (not profits) of the company in the year immediately prior to a conviction, whichever is the greater.

Related topics:
Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice