Manulla NS tragedy


DE FACTO “There is something seriously lacking about an educational system that would allow children to suffer for so long.”
People in power have a serious responsibility towards service. Power is not merely about authority. Power without service is as useful as the proverbial ashtray on a Honda. A power of authority does little more than create victims – the powerless.
It is obvious in Manulla National School that those in positions of power allowed a situation to develop that left many parents with no option but to remove their children from the school. Power in any school is not the sole prerogative of any one person. It is vested in the Board of Management, the patron, the Department of Education, teachers, parents and pupils. Everyone has a role and each role complements the others. When there is a breakdown in that power of service then victims emerge. The first victims are those least able to speak up for themselves – the pupils.
MANAGER’S REPORT
The Minister for Education and Science, Mary Hanafin, has received the manager’s report on Manulla National School, compiled by Mr Brian Hynes. He was appointed as sole manager last March for a six-month period by the school’s patron, the Archbishop of Tuam, Dr Michael Neary, following the resignation of the Board of Management in February. Archbishop Neary has appointed Mr Hynes for a further six months. The ‘imprimatur’ for the re-appointment has to be given by Minister Hanafin. She has not commented formally on the re-appointment, other than to state in a recent Dáil reply to Michael Ring (FG) that she was awaiting the report from the manager before making any further comment.
The manager’s position is probably best described as a no-win situation for Brian Hynes. His report is now on the Minister’s desk. It is up to her to take action. The Minister’s role in this sorry tale cannot be underestimated. At this late stage, it appears that she and she alone is in a position to ensure that justice is done and seen to be done. To date, justice has been denied. It has been withheld from the most vulnerable people in the whole equation, those who have no voice in such circumstances, the school children.
SUFFER LITTLE CHILDREN
There is something seriously lacking about an educational system that would allow children to suffer for so long. The real question is – what is being done to resolve the matter? From a Manulla National School point of view it would appear that very little has been done to date.
That is why it is imperative that the Minister takes decisive and effective action. No one can stand idly by when school numbers have been reduced from the mid 70s to the low 30s.
ISSUES
There are issues and these must be named and dealt with. Some parents sum it up by saying that communication had broken down among certain teachers. When that was noticed then action should have been taken. Instead the matter was allowed to develop or rather fester.
One has to ask why the Board of Management had to resign last February. All teachers are responsible to the Board. Hard decisions have to be made sometimes for the ‘common good.’ Allowing a situation to develop where school numbers were halved was nothing more than a running away from responsibility. This should have been nipped in the bud.
There is so much talk about the power of the union, the Irish National Teachers Organisation. There are mutterings that nothing can happen ‘because of the union.’ The union is made up of people, most of them parents in their own right. They would not like their children to experience what some children in Manulla have experienced.
The INTO cannot stand in the way of any resolution. While their role is to protect teachers who are members, this does not mean that the union would condone members being irresponsible.
Unions have great power but, like any power, it must be of service to be legitimate.