Man cleared of assaulting love rival in Ballyhaunis guesthouse

The case was heard in Castlebar Courthouse.placeholder image
The case was heard in Castlebar Courthouse.

Court heard of alleged assault between two men who had dated the same woman

A MAN who was charged with assaulting a love rival by kicking him in the leg was cleared of the offence at Castlebar District Court.

Prince Nwole with an address in Newtownforbes, Co Longford appeared before a sitting of Castlebar District Court where he was cleared of assault on Volodymyr Cherniavskyi after he was accused of kicking him in the ankle in a Ballyhaunis guesthouse on August 1, 2023.

The court heard that the two men had been in a relationship with Yevhenia Ovdil and the alleged assault took place when she went to collect her belongings from the guest house where Mr Cherniavskyi had been staying.

Mr Cherniavskyi explained that he had been in a relationship with Ms Ovdil in Ukraine before the war and he had followed her to Ireland as refugees.

He explained he settled in a guesthouse in Ballyhaunis while she was in Drumshambo, Co Leitrim and in July 2022 they applied for her to stay in Ballyhaunis with him. The request was successful but the relationship broke up in February 2023 and he said he became aware she was in a new relationship with Mr Nwole who lived in Co Longford.

The court was told that Ms Ovdil went back to Ukraine in June 2023 but she was messaging Mr Cherniavskyi who asked her to come back to Ireland.

He said she agreed and was to return at the end of July. He said he subsequently found out she had stayed in Longford with Mr Nwole before coming to Ballyhaunis.

Giving evidence through an interpreter, Mr Cherniavskyi said Ms Ovdil left the accommodation in Ballyhaunis on July 31, 2023 and returned the next day with the defendant to collect belongings.

He claimed that he wanted to talk to Ms Ovdil alone so he locked the door leaving the defendant outside the room. He then said Mr Nwole damaged the lock on the door and when he came in he claimed he kicked him in the left leg at least twice before leaving.

The court heard that Mr Cherniavskyi's ankle was swollen as a result and he reported the incident to the gardaí the next day.

When questioned by Ms Cathy McDarby, Mr Cherniavskyi accepted he locked Ms Ovdil in his room with him but denied lying about what happened in the guesthouse.

In his evidence Mr Nwone said he was helping his 'woman' take her belongings out of the guesthouse when he was locked out of the room. He said he banged on the door and when it opened he claimed Mr Cherniavskyi swung a punch which he managed to avoid. He said he was acting in self defence at this stage and admitted kicking Mr Cherniavskyi.

Ms McDarby described what happened as 'a storm in a teacup' between two men over one woman and she added it transpired that neither men are now in a relationship with her.

Judge Fiona Lydon dismissed the charge on the basis of the evidence.

Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice