Lost Lives

Second Reading In the merry month of May this year in Ireland two lengthy political careers will come to a close.

“Many of those grievously hurt by the violence in the North over the last 40 years find it hard to be enamoured by the political accord that now exists. They feel that they have paid dearly for it”

Second Reading

Fr Kevin Hegarty

In the merry month of May this year in Ireland two lengthy political careers will come to a close. Bertie Ahern and Dr Ian Paisley are to resign from their respective positions as Taoiseach and First Minister of the Northern Assembly. There is an appropriate serendipity in that their final official meeting will be at the scene of the Battle of the Boyne where they will jointly open an Interpretive Centre on May 6.

I expect the occasion will overflow with joy and bonhomie. There will be a strong note of nostalgia. Nostalgia, often immediately pleasurable, can be unhelpful in the longer perspective. For nostalgia is history with the pain removed.

I have written here recently that the successful conclusion of the Northern Ireland peace process is one of the greatest achievements of democratic politics in the last century. The story of the Northern Ireland conflict is raddled with pain, a pain that now tends to be overlooked in the euphoria that attends the political settlement.

A substantial index of that pain is conveyed in a massive tome, “Lost Lives”, compiled by David McKittrick and Eamon Maillie, which documents the stories of well over 3,000 people who have died as a result of the conflict since the 1960s. The work is comprehensive but it does not highlight the continuing pain of those bereaved by the deaths or badly injured by the bombings and shootings. Behind the bright new dawn in Northern Ireland there is a tragic hinterland of lives thwarted and bodies mutilated.

There have been many works of art - poetry, prose and visual - that have sought to engage with the forty year conflict in the North. Many of them I have found thought-provoking and moving but none more so than a simple ballad, “Claudy”, by the poet, James Simmons. It evokes how the lives of ordinary people in this small town were irrevocably changed by an act of terrorism on a beautiful July day in 1972.

The ballad needs lengthy quotation because the weight of the horror is expressed in the accumulation of detail:

“How peaceful and pretty, if the moment could stop,

McIlhenny is straightening things in his shop,

His wife is outside serving petrol, and then

A girl takes a cloth to a big window-pane.

And McCloskey is taking the weight off his feet,

McClelland and Miller are sweeping the street,

And delivering milk at the Beaufort Hotel,

Young Temple’s enjoying his first job quite well.

And Mrs McLaughlin is scrubbing her floor,

And Artie Hone’s crossing the street to a door,

And Mrs Brown, looking around for her cat,

Goes off up an entry, what’s strange about that?

Not much - but before she comes back to the road

The strange car parked outside her house will explode

And all of the people I’ve mentioned outside

Will be waiting to die or already have died.

An explosion too loud for your eardrums to bear

And young children squalling like pigs in the square,

And all faces chalk-white and streaked with bright red,

And the glass and the dust and the terrible dead.

For an old lady’s legs are ripped off, and the head

Of a man’s hanging open, and he’s still not dead.

He is screaming for mercy, and his son stands and stares,

And stares, and then suddenly, quick, disappears.

And Christ, little Katherine Aiken is dead,

And Mrs McLoughlin is pierced through the head.

Meanwhile to Dungiven the killers have gone,

And they’re finding it hard to get through on the phone.”

It is easy for those who have not been deeply hurt to speak of the need for forgiveness and reconciliation. Clergy, of all denominations, often fall into this trap, for preaching comes easily, often too easily, to us.

Some years ago, an Inter Church Group on Faith and Politics in Ireland, brought out a document, “Burying our Dead”. Its central theme is that we should never preach easy forgiveness. It makes the point that relatives of murder victims were angry at clergy who offered forgiveness to those who committed the crime against their loved ones. The only people who can, or indeed have the right to offer such forgiveness are the relatives and friends. That can take time, maybe even years.

Many of those grievously hurt by the violence in the North over the last 40 years find it hard to be enamoured by the political accord that now exists between Unionist and Nationalists. They feel that they have paid dearly for it.

There is now much talk of how economic growth will follow this political progress. There is a big conference on economic investment to be held in Belfast in May.

There are far more important things in life than economics. There is a need, I believe, in Northern Ireland, for a Truth and Reconciliation Commission, along the lines of the one in South Africa, to aid the process of healing and so copper-fasten the peace process.

Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice