Psychiatrists disagree on whether insanity verdict an option at Mayo murder trial

A Central Criminal Court jury has been told that two psychiatrists disagree on whether a man who is accused of murdering his wife at their rural home in Mayo five years ago satisfies the criteria for a verdict of not guilty by reason of insanity.

Anne-Marie Lawlor, SC, for the Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP), opened the trial of James Kilroy (51) saying that she expects the accused to accept that he killed his wife, Valerie French Kilroy (41).

Ms Kilroy, counsel said, had a violent death having suffered blunt force trauma, strangulation and a stab wound in the rural bungalow she shared with the accused on a road between Castlebar and Westport, at Kilbree, near Islandeady.

Ms Lawlor told the jury of eight women and four men that they will hear from a psychiatrist called by the defence who will say that Mr Kilroy had a mental disorder - cannabis induced psychosis - at the time of the killing.

The psychiatrist will say that Mr Kilroy meets the criteria for a verdict of not guilty by reason of insanity, counsel said.

The late Valerie French Kilroy

The prosecution will call a psychiatrist who will say that in his opinion, Mr Kilroy does not satisfy the criteria for an insanity verdict. Ms Lawlor said that intoxication is not a defence to a murder charge and is not insanity under the law. The jury will therefore hear from two toxicologists as to whether it could be said that Mr Kilroy was intoxicated when he killed his wife.

At the end of the trial, Ms Lawlor said she expects there will be four possible verdicts available to the jury. The DPP's position, she said, is that he is guilty of murder. Mr Kilroy says he is not guilty by reason of insanity. It will also be available to the jury to find him not guilty of murder but guilty of manslaughter on the grounds that his responsibility for the killing was substantially diminished by a mental disorder.

There is the further possibility of a not guilty verdict, but Ms Lawlor said she does 'not see how that arises in this case'.

Mr Kilroy has pleaded not guilty by reason of insanity to murdering his wife at Kilbree Lower, Westport, between June 13 and June 14, 2019. The trial continues before Mr Justice Tony Hunt and the jury.