Lisbon – flowers and the loss of Christian memory

Westport’s thorny Garden of Edenplaceholder image
Westport’s thorny Garden of Eden

De Facto Is General Humbert to blame for re-starting the Lisbon debate? Cardinal Seán Brady gave a powerful speech in his Bishop Stock address.

Liamy MacNally

THERE is a story told about two water jars who journeyed every day on the shoulders of their master. One jar developed a crack and at the end of the journey delivering water to the household it was only half full.

Eventually the cracked jar became embarrassed over its leakage and spoke to its master, stating that it was time to get a new water jar. The master laughed and laughed. The water jar became more embarrassed.

The master then said that under no circumstances would he get a new water jar because of the wonderful work the cracked jar was doing. Amazed, the cracked water jar asked for an explanation, to be told that the master had planted flowers on the trail of the leaking water from the well to his home.

All along that road the leaking water had fed those seeds and an abundance of flowers had grown, which brought the master great pleasure. His journey to the well ensured that not only had he a choice of flowers to admire on the way but he could also pick the choice of flowers for the vases in his house.

The cracked water jar meant that the journey was a pleasure and the house was always covered in fresh blooms.

Last week the hounds of chance and circumstance were unleashed upon the populace. Lisbon looms large on the horizon of hopelessness. Once again, not too long after the referendum’s month’s mind, the Lisbon leotards were donned by the verbal acrobats. They sought to scale the heights of incredulity and astonishment swinging their way from one verbosity to another.

Is General Humbert to blame for re-starting the Lisbon debate? Cardinal Seán Brady was most interesting in his Bishop Stock address to the Humbert School.

It was a powerful speech but at the end some people were wondering why, in God’s name (literally), he did not deliver a similar sea of swirling words prior to the Lisbon Treaty. (The Cardinal’s full address is available on http://www.catholiccommunications.ie/Pressrel/24-august-2008.html). The Cardinal said that in 1999 he attended the second Synod of Bishops on Europe.

It had as its theme ‘Jesus Christ Alive in His Church – the Source of Hope for Europe’. He said: “One of the propositions of the Synod Fathers asked the European Institutions and the States of Europe to recognise that a proper ordering of society must be rooted in authentic, ethical and civic values, shared as widely as possible by its citizens. In the final message, the Synod Fathers called upon the Leaders of Europe to do a number of things – to protest against the violation of human rights of individuals, minorities and peoples; to pay utmost attention to everything that concerns human life from the moment of its conception to natural death, and to pay attention to protect the family based on marriage, for these are the foundations on which our common European home rests….In 2003, in his subsequent reflection on the Synod, Pope John Paul II … while noting his respect for the secular nature of the European institutions, went on to ask that any such treaty would include a reference to the religious and Christian heritage of Europe.

He also asked that three things would be recognised: the right of churches and religious communities to organise themselves freely in conformity with their proper convictions; that the Union respect the specific identity of the different religious confessions and make provision for a structured dialogue between the European Union and those confessions; that the union would have respect for the juridical status already enjoyed by churches and religious institutions within the states of the Union.…As the recent referendum on the Lisbon Treaty in Ireland suggests, at least some of those who were previously enthusiastic about the founding aims of the EU, both social and economic, are now expressing unease.

The reasons for this are complex. But one reason influencing some Christians may be what Pope John Paul II described as the ‘loss of Christian memory’ in European institutions and policy. Successive decisions which have undermined the family based on marriage, the right to life from the moment of conception to natural death, the sacredness of the Sabbath, the right of Christian institutions to maintain and promote their ethos, including schools, these and other decisions have made it more difficult for committed Christians to maintain their instinctive commitment to the European project.”

Perhaps Minister Dick Roche, Gay Mitchell (who disgraced himself on national radio because of his personal attacks on Ulick McEvaddy and Declan Ganley) and their cohorts might just stop and think.

Maybe the ‘No’ vote is pushing us towards Christian memory and appreciating the flowers on the roadside.

Should we apologise or will we settle for Danish opt-outs? 

Related topics:
Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice