Knock Airport and Bord Snip
Contrary to perceptions, Ireland West Airport Knock does not large state subsidies, says Liam Scollan.
“Most people might perceive that airports like Ireland West Airport Knock receive large state subsidies while airports such as Cork and Shannon operate commercially. Nothing could be further from the truth.”
Liam Scollan
THE McCarthy Report fails to put the spotlight on the considerable level of State largesse provided to the State’s own regional airports, Cork and Shannon, and focuses instead on the much less significant funding interventions made to the so called ‘regional airports’ - Waterford, Kerry, Galway, IWA Knock, Sligo and Donegal.
It is incredible that a report charged with recommending cuts in public expenditure ignores the largest beneficiaries of State support when it comes to aviation.
I wholeheartedly agree with rationalisation of aviation expenditure. The State’s own regional airports, Cork and Shannon, get free air traffic control worth over €2.5m per year respectively; €250m of capital funding; Government funding support to fight legal battles with airlines that challenge them; other State bodies like Bus Éireann supplying customers to their door and millions of additional support in tourism funding aimed specifically at promoting their inbound routes from the UK and elsewhere.
By contrast, Ireland West Airport has received no operational aid from the Government in the last three years, pays from its own resources for all the services such as air traffic control, which the competing State airports get for free and furthermore the region it serves (the West and North West) gets a tiny fraction of the overseas tourism marketing support provided into the southern region, while Bus Éireann, a state body, transports passengers from its region direct to Dublin Airport.
In fact the €2m per year of Core Operational Grant aid that the other so called ‘ regional airports’ get combined, is a miserable fraction of the largesse provided for decades to the State’s own airports.
Most people might perceive that airports like IWA Knock receive large state subsidies while airports such as Cork and Shannon operate commercially. Nothing could be further from the truth. Ireland West Airport Knock has not received any operational subsidy from the Government in the last three years and prior to that received very little operational aid. In fact it has to compete in a market where the State airports are given enormous competitive advantages from the State.
By contrast the two State airports, and particularly Shannon, benefit financially from a continuing level of State intervention which is not sustainable. They benefit from huge State-guaranteed loans for capital investment worth €250m which dwarfs that invested in other airports. Parts of their entire operations are funded by the taxpayer. For example free air traffic control services and facilities are provided by the State body, the Irish Aviation Authority (IAA), to Dublin, Cork and Shannon airports. Over 30 Air traffic controllers are employed at each of Shannon and Cork airports, with costs met by the State body the Irish Aviation Authority at an average cost per employee of almost €90,000 annually. By contrast Ireland West Airport trains and pays for its own. This one hidden subsidy alone is worth over €2.5m annually to each airport and the value to Dublin Airport is three times this amount. This one subsidy in one year dwarfs all operational aids provided to all the other airports combined over several years.
The McCarthy Report unfortunately accepts the status quo of State support for State airports, a status quo which sees the State airports cushioned by tax payer handouts and by imposed levy payments from competing independent airports and thereby ensures that an inefficient, inequitable and ultimately tax payer-supported aviation system will continue.
In light of the proposals in the McCarthy Report, Ireland West Airport Knock wishes to call for a detailed assessment by Government of the viability of all regional airports including the former Aer Rianta airports prior to implementing sweeping changes. This will result in more savings, more commercial viability within airports and bring about a balanced approach to the achievement of the targeted savings and additional revenues, in addition to maintaining air access services to specific regions, and in particular the West and North West .
However, this is never going to happen until the Government reverses the interventions it is making to sustain its own State airports and allows IWA Knock to compete on level terms and in a manner where it can continue to provide international connectivity at minimal or even zero cost to the taxpayer in the decades ahead.
Liam Scollan is currently Chairman of Ireland West Airport Knock.