Judgement on lotto row deferred

JUDGEMENT has been reserved in a Supreme Court appeal by four members of a winning Lotto syndicate against a court order that a Bohola man is entitled to a one-fifth share of the €2 million prize.

Judgement on Lotto row deferred

Áine Ryan

JUDGEMENT has been reserved in a Supreme Court appeal by four members of a winning Lotto syndicate against a court order that Martin Horan, of Carragown, Bohola, Castlebar, is entitled to a one-fifth share of the €2 million prize.

On Wednesday last, November 26, the three-judge court heard submissions against a High Court ruling that Martin Horan was entitled to €400,000 of the Lotto winnings.

Presiding Mr Justice Hugh Geoghegan, along with Mr Justice Niall Fennelly and Mr Justice Joseph Finnegan, said the court would reserve judgment in light of the complex evidence.

Originally, Mr Horan had brought the High Court action which alleged he was excluded from the winning syndicate by four members of it – Frank O’Reilly, a publican, of O’Reilly’s pub, Ballyvary, Castlebar; Michael McHale, a farmer, of Curranee, Ballyvary; John Joyce, a taxi driver, of Keelogues, Ballyvary; and Seamus O’Brien, also a taxi driver, of Ballyvary.

Mr Justice Frank Clarke, in a High Court decision in December 2004, ruled Mr Horan was entitled to a one-fifth share of the prize and also awarded costs estimated at some €100,000 to Mr Horan against the other four members of the syndicate.

On the other hand, the four men argued Mr Horan was removed from the syndicate in October 2000, some months before the jackpot win of January 6, 2001, because he was in arrears of contributions and had told the syndicate organiser, Mr Seamus O’Brien, to ‘f*** off’ when Mr O’Brien approached him in a bar asking him to pay arrears.

However, Mr Horan denied he had made such comments to Mr O’Brien, claimed he had always paid arrears in lump sums, and had never been removed from the syndicate.

In his judgment, Mr Justice Clarke had said he accepted Mr Horan’s evidence as broadly correct.

In their appeal, the four syndicate members argued the trial judge erred in finding Mr Horan was a member of the syndicate when, they contend, he had not contributed anything to the purchase of the winning ticket and had not arranged for any contribution to be made on his behalf.

Related topics:
Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice