Judge questions prosecutors after Westport crash
A LONG-running case arising out of a fatal road traffic accident on the Ballinrobe Road outside Westport on July 17, 2006 concluded in Westport District Court last week.
Judge questions prosecutors in fatal Westport traffic accident case
A LONG-running case arising out of a fatal road traffic accident on the Ballinrobe Road outside Westport on July 17, 2006 concluded in Westport District Court last week, with Judge Mary Devins stating that the charges brought against the defendant were nothing more than ‘window-dressing and a sop to public opinion and the close connections of the dead man’.
Mr Patrick Ryder (33), a train driver from Tavanaghmore, Foxford, appeared before Westport District Court on charges arising out of the road traffic accident which claimed the life of Mr Angelo Forcina, owner of ‘La Bella Vita’ restaurant on High Street in Westport, which has since ceased trading.
Mr Ryder was charged with having no road tax; failing to report the occurrence (accident) as soon as possible to a member of An Garda Síochána; failing to give the appropriate information; failing to drive on the left hand side of the road and not having a tax disc displayed. He pleaded guilty to the charge relating to having no tax and was convicted of this and fined €300, but pleaded not guilty to the other charges – all of which were dismissed.
After giving her judgement, Judge Devins said that this was a fatal and tragic road traffic accident, and that people were still suffering because of it. She said the DPP did not direct a prosecution for dangerous driving causing death and it was her view that the local prosecutors formed a view on this and brought further charges against the defendant – for which the evidence did not stand up.
It is, she said, ‘almost impossible not to consider these prosecutions as anything other than window-dressing and a sop to public opinion and the close connections of the dead man’, before Superintendent Pat Doyle rose to his feet to respond.
He informed Judge Devins that the DPP considered every matter in the case and not the local prosecutors.
“I have no authority to institute any proceedings in cases of this nature,” he said. “They are all done by the DPP and not by me and I want to make that clear for the record.”
Judge Devins said she was glad to clarify this.
In Achill District Court last month, Patrick Ryder recalled the same details as those contained in the written statement he made to Gardaí after the accident. He was driving a ‘94 Toyota MR2 but did not recall how he was driving and could not remember seeing anyone at the scene and did not know why he did not stay at the scene. He said that, judging by the state of his clothes, he and Joe Davis (his passenger) must have walked back to Mr Davis’ house through the fields. Later, his brother-in-law came to the house and told them about the accident, and he presented at Westport Garda Station around 5.50am.
Earlier that night he went for dinner with Joe Davis and his brother and parents and drank one pint of Guinness. Afterwards, they went to The Jester pub in Westport where Mr Davis had an altercation and the defendant brought him outside. They walked back to the house and Mr Davis asked to be brought for a spin as he was upset. The defendant said in his statement that he remembered seeing blinding lights and had glass in the side of his head, but had no recollection of a large part of what happened.
Dr John Connolly, a psychiatrist, also previously gave evidence and said that he had met with Patrick Ryder on 16 occasions since the accident. He said the defendant seemed to have no personal memory of the accident other than being upside down in the car and trying to get out, and that he had completely emotionally detached himself from the scene and the car. He added that an incident such as this could cause post-traumatic stress disorder.
Last week, defending solicitor Rory O’Connor said that his client did not know he had been involved in the accident until his brother-in-law came to his house later that night. He said the post-traumatic stress had led to his memory loss, and the duty to report an accident is lifted when a driver is incapacitated according to Section 106 of the Road Traffic Act. He said the case boiled down to whether or not the judge believed that the defendant had no memory of the accident, as the psychiatrist had stated. He said there was no evidence as to the point of impact and therefore no evidence that he was not as close to his own side of the road as he should have been – which was one of the charges brought against him. Mr O’Connor added that his client’s life had also been ruined, and that he had not worked since the accident.
Superintendent Pat Doyle responded that the defendant was not incapacitated, as somebody who leaves the scene of an accident could not be considered so, and stated that he did have a duty to report the accident as soon as possible.
On the charge of failing to drive on the left side of the road, Judge Devins dismissed, saying that the evidence of the point of impact from the investigations carried out was based on possibility not probability.
On the charge of failing to provide appropriate information, Judge Devins said that the relevant section of the Road Traffic Act provides that if a garda is not present at the scene of an accident then a person involved shall give, on demand, appropriate information to a person, including those present at the scene. Dismissing the charge, she said that nobody at the scene demanded information from the defendant and therefore the charge of failing to give appropriate information was fundamentally flawed.
Judge Devins then turned to what she called the ‘biggie of a small bunch of matters’ – failure to report the occurrence (the accident) as soon as possible to a member of An Garda Síochána and, if necessary, to go for that purpose to the nearest convenient Garda Síochána station and give, on demand, the appropriate information (about the accident) to the member.
Judge Devins said she had listened to the evidence on this point, and to that of the psychiatrist, and in the absence of contradictory evidence on the defendant’s state of mind from another expert, she believed he was acting irrationally and continued to be in need of psychiatric care.
Judge Devins felt that the fact the defendant left a car clearly identifiable as his on the road and went back to the house he was staying in after the accident showed that he was acting irrationally as opposed to fleeing the scene. She added that he was in a traumatic state and once he was informed of the accident he went to the Garda station and volunteered the information, which could be interpreted as being ‘as soon as possible’ in this circumstance. Judge Devins also dismissed this charge before convicting the defendant of not having tax and fining him €300.