Judge apologises to Gardaí for not doing job properly
A CIRCUIT Court Judge apologises to Gardaí for not doing job properly before sending man back to prison to serve remainder of his four year term
Judge apologises to Gardaí for not doing job properly
A JUDGE publicly apologised to the Gardaí at last week’s sitting of Castlebar Circuit Criminal court after he sentenced a 19-year-old man to prison for failing to comply with a court order.
Mr Charlie Ward, who lives on the Ballymote Road, Charlestown, was released from Castlerea prison on March 28 last after being sentenced to four years’ imprisonment in 2007 for assaulting a Garda sergeant. The offence occurred on July 15, 2006 when gardaí were attempting to arrest Mr Ward in Charlestown.
Mr Ward struck Sergeant Eamon O’Donnell, who was off-duty at the time, in the face and caused an estimated €40,000 to €60,000 worth of dental injuries. The final two-and-a-half years of Mr Ward’s sentence was suspended on condition that, on his release, he entered Harristown House for treatment and came under the supervision of the Probation Services for a further three years and remained out of trouble.
However, Ms Helena Morrin, Probation Officer with the Probation Services said that Mr Ward had failed to comply with the court conditions and asked for his case to be re-entered. She said that he had failed to deal with his alcohol problem and since his release he was convicted of assault.
Ms Morrin told the court that when Mr Ward was due to be admitted into Harristown House on June 12, he was unable to attend because he was undergoing surgery on an ulcer. She said he had to be re-assessed and when he was assessed on August 27, he was deemed unsuitable because he appeared intoxicated and he had to be alcohol and drug free to be admitted. She said he was given another re-assessment date for November 5 on the condition that he underwent urinalysis with his GP and showed motivation to deal with his problem.
However, she said he had re-offended since his release and, on September 26 last, he received a three-month suspended sentence for an incident on July 25 last. She said his alcohol situation was very serious and was out of control, and he recently put his hand through a caravan window.
Under questioning from Mr Eoin Garavan, BL, for Mr Ward (instructed by Mr Alan Gannon), Ms Morrin said that he was not breathalysed when he was re-assessed and appeared intoxicated. Mr Ward claimed he did not take alcohol on the day but took a valium tablet and smoked a joint and that is why he appeared drowsy.
However, Judge Groarke said he was in breach of the court conditions because of his conviction regardless of whether or not he could be admitted to Harristown House. He said the assault was a nasty case but he had hoped that Mr Ward would have been able to avail of the opportunity given to him.
He told Mr Ward that he had taken a leap of faith with him and apologised to the Gardaí for not doing his job properly. He told Mr Ward there would be no second chance. He directed that Mr Ward go to prison to serve the suspended sentence, backdated to September 26. He said he hoped Mr Ward would get a bit of sense sooner or later.