Irish accountability

placeholder image

De Facto More and more people are realising that there is very little accountability in this country.

SOFTENING ROAR 'Perhaps we will have to wait until the rub of the relic we call the Celtic Tiger has worn off before we stand up and be counted, together.'

Making accountability matter – Irish-style

De Facto

Liamy McNally

More and more people are realising that there is very little accountability in this country. Government departments, state-sponsored bodies, statutory bodies, local authorities and the HSE all fall down when it comes to delivering what can be described as a proper service. There are notable exceptions in some sections, but generally the trend is towards sloppiness and a lack of accountability. The common denominator is that this folly is paid for by the taxpayer who does not have a say in such daft decision-making. 

We can all list a series of scandals and bad management practices that have cost taxpayers millions of euro, from PPARS to electronic voting machines that are still being held in storage sheds and are now so out of date that the scrap heap would be a welcome repose for their condition. We should be reciting ‘May they rust in peace’, but instead we still pay out millions to keep the rain off them. Who is accountable? Martin Cullen? Ha!

LIGHTEN UP!

The ESB is encouraging people to use the ‘cheaper’ night-time electricity. It sounds lovely but the reality is different. The nocturnal live wires have just discovered that they are being charged a higher rate for their day-time usage of power and the ‘standing charge’ is also higher than ‘regular’ customers. (When will the ESB standing charge be paid? ‘Rural electrification’ is over 50 years’ old.) They must also pay €256 to have a second meter installed for the night-time rate. Rip-off Ireland, greed or incompetence? Accountability?

Try the private sector. You can borrow less than €20,000 from a certain financial institution. The rate will be around 9.6 per cent. Should you borrow a higher amount the rate will be lower, but if you borrow €21,000 at the new lower rate and draw down less than the approved amount you will be penalised for paying back the loan too quickly! The only accountability here is the bottom line. The records of the major banks speak for themselves. Most have been involved in wrongdoing. The only accountability is that they were caught and were embarrassed into re-paying what was wrongly taken from people’s accounts. 

Then there are water rates, or water ‘charges’ as they are affectionately known. Commercial users, like farmers, must pay water rates later this year. That did not stop Mayo County Council blitzing farmers with water bills last year. Many farmers, especially the elderly, paid up, thinking that the bills were bona fide.

When it was brought to the attention of all concerned monies were returned. Under the new water rates regulations, all farmers with herd numbers are obliged to pay water charges. It sounds reasonable but what about the farmer who has a small squad of sheep that s/he will keep for a few months (as demanded by REPS) and not have any recourse to a water supply? As it stands s/he must pay!

It is as if there is some little ‘maneen’ sitting in some little desk in some little obscure office making up the daftest rules he can imagine just to further frustrate the lives of people who are finding it rather difficult to make ends meet even as the dust clouds of the Celtic Tiger’s exit settles.

HEALTH AND SAFETY BACK-PEDDLING

Move on to the current oral hearing being conducted by An Bord Pleanála (under Dick Roche’s fast-track major infrastructural projects shameful ‘law’) about the proposed gas terminal on the Shannon estuary near Tarbert in north Kerry. Last week the Health & Safety Authority (HSA), which advises local authorities ‘against or not against’ a major project, stated that the Shannon project had met the necessary criteria.

An Irish Times report stated that following evidence presented at the oral hearing over two days and documents submitted on January 11 ‘which it had not had time to assess properly’, the HSA stated the advice could be reviewed! Ah, lads! What is going on? Another state-sponsored company with a penchant for changing its mind. The Corrib gas oral hearing comes to mind. 

The week also presented information from the Environmental Protection Agency on water quality. Some people claim that this body should be renamed. Westport water supply had EIGHT times the permitted level of aluminium. Were Covies informed that their brain cells were threatened to such a degree? No way!

Those in ‘power’ probably forgot, using the high concentration of aluminium levels as their excuse! The EPA is still investigating the cause of the high levels.

They are formally notified after the HSE is notified of such levels following a water test. Did the HSE advise Westport consumers of aluminium levels in water?

ACCOUNTABILITY

It keeps coming back to one word – accountability. Pick any issue that is topical, even the Irish translation of place names on road signs. There are so many so embarrassingly wrong yet there is no accountability. Many people will engage in the dithering dance to move the issue from their ‘inbox’ but no one will assume responsibility, not even the great white hope of the so-called republican party, Éamon Ó Cuív. 

Who will back the ‘small man’ against the might and force of oppressive officialdom? Whoever you are, where are you now when we need you? Did we elect a complete gang of badógs who are unwilling or unable to do anything about the gross ineptitude that is so evident?

And back to the inshore fishermen of Erris, our county men, in a recent submission to Ministers Éamon Ó Cuív and Eamon Ryan, expressing concern over the Corrib effluent pipe into the pristine Broadhaven Bay. Edited extracts state: “With the advent of Shell in Erris, things have changed, changed drastically. They have intruded into our lives, not on any invitation from us but by permission of our legislative authority to develop and exploit the natural resources off our shores for their own benefit and seemingly to their own sole advantage.

Shell’s only reason for being in Erris is to make a profit…Unfortunately their claim of wanting to be good neighbours sounds very hollow in view of their methods and practices since their arrival…

“Is it any wonder then that discontent is setting in, discontent that has the potential to develop into confrontation? We do not want that. Must we change our tactics to be listened to or responded to in a reasonable way?...

“We have asked questions of Shell and got answers that were contemptuous of our intelligence. We have responded to their calls for dialogue, only to find out that dialogue, Shell-style, is that we sit down with them, make our points, accept their explanations and admit that they were right all along… We…sought a meeting with the then minister of the DCMNR, Noel Dempsey. The answers we got back were, either practically word for word what we got from Shell and their fore runners EEI, or to questions we did not ask.  We were never granted a meeting…” 

Accountability, Irish Government-style. Perhaps we will have to wait until the rub of the relic we call the Celtic Tiger has worn off before we stand up and be counted, together.

Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice