Inquest adjourned for another independent witness

The inquest into the death of a Castlebar women who died hours after giving birth has again been adjourned to allow an independent witness to review the records held at Mayo General Hospital.

Inquest adjourned for independent witness

Anton McNulty

THE inquest into the death of a Castlebar women who died hours after giving birth has once again been adjourned to allow an independent witness from the Royal College of Obstetricians to review the records held at Mayo General Hospital.

Mrs Evelyn Flanagan (38) (pictured) from Hollyhill, Ballyheane, died after giving birth on October 19, 2007, and her inquest which had been part-heard last September was adjourned to allow an independent witness from the Royal College of Pathologists in London to review all the files of the post-mortem.

Dr Fadel Bennani, Pathologist at Mayo General Hospital, who conducted the post-mortem on Mrs Flanagan, had concluded that amniotic fluid embolism (AFE) was the cause of death but he had never personally come across a case before as it is very rare. His conclusion was contested by the counsel for Mrs Flanagan’s husband, Pádraic, who argued the cause of death was massive haemorrhage rather than amniotic fluid embolism.

At yesterday’s sitting of Castlebar Coroner’s Court, Mr John O’Dwyer explained that the Royal College of Pathologists had nominated Dr Ken West to review the post-mortem files and had forwarded his report to the respective parties. He also said he received correspondence from Mr Michael Browne, solicitor for Mr Flanagan, seeking to have Derek Tufnell, Consultant Obstetrician, give evidence at the inquest, but the the HSE had objected to the proposal.

In his submission, Mr O’Dwyer said the jury was the sole arbiter of the facts and all the facts should be fully investigated to allow them to reach a verdict. He said as the coroner he was obliged to put all the evidence before the jury.

He said he would not allow Mr Browne’s proposal to call Dr Tuffnell but would ask for the Royal College of Obstetricians to put forward a witness to review the files and look into the care of Mrs Flanagan.

Mr John Jordan, BL for Mr Flanagan, said they were happy with Dr West’s report but were concerned that he had no personal experience with AFE. He added that it was important that the consultant appointed by the Royal College of Obstetricians had personal experience of AFE.

Mr O’Dwyer said he had set out the terms of engagement with the Royal College of Pathologists and they had given him the name of Dr West. He said any nominee from the Royal College of Obstetricians will be given the same transcripts and files as Dr West.

Mr O’Dwyer said that Dr West was due to give evidence on February 9 but he expressed his wish that the two independent witnesses give their evidence on the same day. No date was given for the re-commencement of the inquest.

In a related matter, Mr O’Dwyer asked why the HSE and Mayo General Hospital did not hold an official enquiry into the death of Mrs Flanagan and asked for a representative of the hospital to explain their position. He said he had been made aware of a case from Drogheda where a report of an inquiry had been made available to the coroner and an inquiry had been undertaken after a maternity death in Tralee. The solicitor for the HSE said that he would have to speak to Mr Tony Canavan, General Manager for Mayo General Hospital, about the issue but he was out sick.

Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice