HSE pays €1.5m to Bohola teenager with Cerebral Palsy

‘Cerebral palsy won’t kill me, but I have to learn to live with it. This shouldn’t have happened to me’ – teen

HSE pays €1.5m to Bohola teenager with Cerebral Palsy

Áine Ryan

FOCUS should be on the ‘abilities’ and not the ‘disabilities’ of a teenage girl with Cerebral Palsy whose family last week secured an interim payment of €1.5 million from the HSE due to alleged negligence  during her birth at Mayo General Hospital, Castlebar, on October 11, 1999.

That is the view of the family’s solicitor, Michael Boylan, who said, outside the High Court that Mary’s future was now secure. “She was immensely brave to read her statement in court. You have to focus on her abilities, not her disabilities. She is a real winner,” he said.

Earlier, inside the court, sitting in a wheelchair Ms Mary Malee, of Shanaghy, Bohola, Swinford, read a short statement in which she said her condition is not equivalent to having a broken leg in a cast for eight weeks, but a life condition.

“Cerebral palsy won’t kill me, but I have to learn to live with it. This shouldn’t have happened to me and others like me. It would have been appreciated had the HSE/Mayo General Hospital, Castlebar said they were sorry, but at least the payment of the compensation lessens the future financial worries,” she said.  

The High Court settlement was made without admission of liability but the case will return to the court in two years for the assessment of future care needs, which will include a house expected to cost €500,000.

Mr Aongus O’BrolchΡin SC, for Ms Malee, said she was a ‘very bright and terribly popular’ girl with terrific family support, who hoped to proceed to third level education.

It was alleged that at Mary’s birth there was failure to intervene and carry out a caesarean section in a proper and timely manner and failure to ensure the presence of a skilled paediatrician at the birth of the baby. It was also alleged it was known in advance of delivery the baby was suffering foetal distress and likely to require expert resuscitation.

The HSE denied the claims.

Outlining the claim, Mr O’BrolchΡin said Mrs Maura Malee had attended the consultant gynaecologist who had delivered her other children and on October 8, 1999, he advised her she had raised blood pressure and to go to hospital the next day and be prepared for induction of labour.

The gynaecologist told her he would not be able to attend as he had a cancer diagnosis but would make arrangements for her care to be transferred to another consultant.

Mrs Malee attended her GP on October 9, who told her to go to hospital immediately as she had symptoms of pre-eclampsia. She was admitted to hospital and on October 11 was transferred to the labour ward, where a CTG (Cardiotocography) trace was commenced. Another CTG shortly after 6am showed a series of decelerations and a consultant was called but he was in Letterkenny. Another consultant then was called and assisted in the delivery. Counsel said the delivery was complicated and Mary was not born until 7.20am. A caesarean should have been carried out earlier, the counsel claimed.

Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice