HSE apologise after delay in cancer diagnosis of Ballindine man
The family of a deceased Ballindine man are relieved with an apology from the HSE over delay in diagnosis of cancer.
HSE apologise after delay in cancer diagnosis of Ballindine man
Michael Commins
THE widow of a Mayo man who died after a two year delay by the HSE in diagnosing cancer has said the apology from the HSE last week was the most important thing she set out to achieve when the case was settled in Dublin. The High Court approved a settlement of the case against the HSE in which total damages were agreed at €102,000.
The Health Service Executive apologised to Eileen McNeive and her family from Logalisheen, Ballindine. Her husband John (59) died after a two-year delay in diagnosing the cancer. He was first referred to Galway Regional Hospital in April 2003.Despite a series of tests there and at Beaumont Hospital in Dublin, cancer of the neck was not diagnosed until two years after - in April 2005. He died four months later.
John, a native of Ballykilleen, Cloonfad, was well known and respected around the Ballindine area where he resided with his wife Eileen and sons David and Michael. He had been confined to a wheelchair for many years.
Mr McNeive had surgery in 1966 to remove a brain tumour and had a shunt inserted back then. In 2003 he began suffering from headaches and was referred to Galway Hospital. He was seen by a neurologist and a year later developed a swelling on his face. A CT scan carried out at Beaumont Hospital in August 2004 showed a malignant tumour.
Follow-up appointments and a biopsy, which had been recommended, were not carried out and it was a year later before his diagnosis was confirmed. He died in a hospice in August 2005.
The McNeive family said they wanted to highlight their case in the hope that lessons could be learned and that systems within the HSE would improve. The court was told that the HSE acknowledged that there was a delay in the diagnosis of Mr McNeive and that his family could have done no more to help him. The HSE also apologised for the hurt and distress caused to the family.
Included in the settlement is a payment of just over €25,000 for mental distress which will be divided among Mr McNeive’s widow, his two sons and his seven siblings. Approving the settlement Mr Justice John Quirke conveyed his sympathy to the McNeive family, saying he had some idea how dreadful it must have been for them.
The case and its outcome attracted considerable media attention and was featured on the main evening news on RTE and other channels. An apology from a state body is quite rare and few of this nature have been forthcoming from the HSE or the Heath Boards over the years.