Hotels accused of exploitation
The hotel industry in Mayo has been accused of exploiting foreign workers.
Hotels accused of exploitation
> Pay below minimum wage
> Hours worked too long
> Holiday entitlements not given
Anton McNulty
THE HOTEL industry in Mayo has been accused of exploiting foreign workers and members – with one Bangladeshi man claiming he has only received one day off in two years. A number of employers in the hotel industry have been accused of exploiting immigrant workers by not adhering to the employment regulation order, which sets down minimum conditions. They have been accused of breaching many sections of the order, including not paying workers the minimum wage, not paying for over-time work and not introducing the Sunday premium rate, while some workers were not being paid the correct holiday rate and in some cases employers were withholding payment for a number of weeks.
Hotels now face the prospect of having their accounts audited by the Department of Enterprise, Trade and Employment in the New Year.
One Bangladeshi national told The Mayo News that he worked as a kitchen porter in a well-known Mayo hotel for over two years and was only given one day off in that time. He said the hotel management told him they were applying for his work permit but later found out they had not applied, allowing his working visa to expire.
“I would work long hours, sometimes for 70 hours a week at Christmas time, and once I asked for one Saturday off and, while I got it, they gave me trouble after that. I worked for two years and I never got one weekend off. I asked the management but I was told that I was not working legally and I shouldn’t get it. They also promised me they were applying for my work permit but they did not apply at the right time. I had a seven-month working visa when I started and it was only when it expired that they applied.
“I started the job as a kitchen porter but I had experience as a chef and soon I was working as a chef. However, I was getting paid as a kitchen porter for the whole time even though I was working as a chef. I did not mind working those long hours because I needed the money, and it was the only way I would get it,” he explained.
SIPTU official and Castlebar town councillor, Michael Kilcoyne told The Mayo News that this exploitation was allowed to happen because employees were afraid to speak out at the risk of losing their job. He said he was ‘bombarded’ by calls from a number of concerned workers after he gave a talk on employment legislation at a seminar for foreign nationals last week.
He explained that he took the details from a number of workers and was going to refer their cases to the labour inspectors in the Department of Enterprise, Trade and Employment to allow audits to be carried out in the businesses involved.
“There is a widespread exploitation of workers and they are being used to generate higher profits for the people employing them. The employees certainly don’t know their rights and in many cases they are being badly treated, particularly in the hotel and catering industry. These places are, by and large, in Mayo and a number of reputable employers have contacted me to say that such and such a place was not paying the correct rates. That is also providing unfair competition to the employer paying the correct rate.
“The new Director of the industrial inspectorate section in the Department is a man called Ger Deering, who was the former taxi regulator. He is extremely efficient and it is clear to me that he is not going to accept any nonsense. Inspectors from the Department will go in and carry out a total audit and compare working rosters with payroll records. An employer may have someone working for 60 hours and put down that they were working for 40 hours. It is my opinion that there will be prosecutions as a result because the inspectors are not going to take any more nonsense,” he said.
However, these claims were rejected by Mr John Power, Chief Executive of the Irish Hotels Federation, who said that he did believe that the exploitation of workers was widespread in Irish hotels. He told The Mayo News that 34 per cent of hotel workers in Ireland are foreign nationals and if any hotels were found to be exploiting workers, they would have to be brought into line.
“To be honest, if there is evidence of exploitation of workers they should go to the labour inspectors and we would welcome inspections and audits. However, I don’t believe it is widespread and the vast majority of employees comply with the regulations. Over the years there have been very few hotels in breach of the employment regulations and the ones that have are usually because of technical breaches.
“We also feel these matters are being sensationalised by SIPTU at this time of year and last year I had to defend the hotel industry in Kerry after a similar outburst by a SIPTU official. The number of hotel inspectors has been beefed up in recent times from 21 to 90 and the new Director, Ger Deering is a very balanced individual, and will give a whole approach to any complaint. But if there are black sheep out there, they will have to be brought into line,” he concluded.