High Court rules sheep grazing case will be heard


TWO sheep farmers who had a prosecution brought against them for allowing their sheep to graze on protected lands dismissed in the District Court, will have the matter heard again after a High Court judge ruled that the District Court judge was incorrect in her ruling.
TWO sheep farmers who had a prosecution brought against them for allowing their sheep to graze on protected lands dismissed in the District Court, will have the matter heard again after a High Court judge ruled that the District Court judge was incorrect in her ruling.
Last year, a landmark case was brought against Mr Michael Joseph Leneghan and Mr Patrick McHugh both with addresses at Tarsaghaun Beg North, Ballycroy by the Department of the Environment, Heritage and Local Government after they were accused of allowing their sheep to graze in a habitat protected by EU regulations. Their case was dismissed by Judge Mary Devins who ruled that the Department of the Environment needed to prove the two farmers intended to break the law, but agreed to refer a case to the High Court on the point of law raised.
At last week’s High Court ruling made by Mr Justice John Hedigan, he said the regulations would be ‘largely ineffectual’ if the State had to prove beyond reasonable doubt a person had such an intention.
“In light of the foregoing, I am of the opinion that the offence created by Regulation 4 (3) of the 2005 Regulations is one of strict liability. I would therefore answer the question referred in the case stated in the negative and hold that the learned District Judge was incorrect in finding that a ‘mens rea’ element needed to be proven,” he stated.
The State Solicitor, Mr Seamus Hughes confirmed to The Mayo News that the case will now be re-entered before the District Court. “The case will now come before the District Court for hearing and will be heard in the Ballycroy sitting in Achill District Court. A date has not yet been fixed but will go ahead sooner rather than later,” he said.
The farmers faced a complaint from the Department, that they had allowed their sheep to graze on protected lands, outside of the designated season. Under the European Birds and Habitats Directive, farmers must remove their livestock from the Owenduff/Nephin Complex Special Protection Area (SPA) during November and December and between February 15 and May 15 every year. The defendants were alleged to have allowed their sheep to graze in the restricted area in May of 2007, and when detected, nine sheep and ten lambs were seized.