High Court overturns Shell contempt ruling
Shell have welcomed last week’s High Court decision to overturn a finding that it was in contempt of court.
High Court overturns Shell contempt ruling
Áine Ryan
SHELL E&P (SEPIL) Ireland has welcomed last week’s High Court decision to overturn a finding that it was in contempt of court when, almost two years ago, its agents entered commonage lands at Rossport.
Last Friday, the President of the High Court, Mr Justice Nicholas Kearns ruled that a November 2007 order by District Court Judge Mary Devins (pictured) restraining entry on to the commonage, unless in accordance with the Gas Act 1976, did not prevent Shell entering on to the commonage, after the company acquired a 1/62nd share of the lands.
Shell’s agents went on to the lands in July and August 2008, after it acquired the share in the commonage, which traverses a former proposed route for the controversial pipeline.
Rossport South resident Monica Muller, a co-owner of the commonage, then applied to have the company held in contempt of the November 2007 order. She claimed that Shell should not have entered the lands for the purpose of carrying out tests without having first applied to Judge Devins to vacate the order and without Ms Muller’s consent.
After Judge Devins ruled Shell was technically in contempt in September 2009, Shell appealed and Judge Devins referred certain legal issues for determination by the High Court.
In his reserved judgement, Mr Justice Kearns said it was clear the November 2007 order did not absolutely prohibit any entry whatsoever on to the commonage lands by Shell. He also ruled that the order, made under Section 26.4 of the Gas Act, could not prohibit entry by Shell on to the commonage after it acquired a share in the commonage. He observed it would have been a different matter if there had been proof of pipe-laying or excavations.
Regarding the penal nature of a contempt finding, the District Court would have to be satisfied beyond reasonable doubt before finding a breach of its order had been committed, he said.
It was clear District Judge Devins did not intend her order to prohibit entry on to the land in all circumstances, he also noted.
In conclusion, Justice Kearns ruled that the matter did not fulfill the requisite legal standard to justify the finding by Judge Devins that Shell was guilty of civil contempt.
Welcoming the ruling, a Shell spokesman stated: “The finding of contempt, which was made in September 2009, related to survey work which the company had carried out previously on Rossport commonage. SEPIL always acted in good faith in relation to its survey work and is pleased that this approach has been upheld by the President of the High Court.”