Heart attack and not foul play caused death of Carrowteigue man

Foul play ruled out in the death of an Erris man who was found unconscious with a dislocated shoulder and fractured skull

Anton McNulty

The State Pathologist has ruled out foul play in the death of an Erris man who was found unconscious on the side of the road with a dislocated shoulder.

Christopher Doherty of Carrowteigue, Ballina, was found unconscious beside Carrowteigue NS on October 9, 2015, and despite extensive efforts to rehabilitate him, he was pronounced dead at the scene.

The 76-year-old man was seen walking along the side of the road just minutes before he was found unconscious and a post-mortem was performed due to the sudden nature of his death.

During the initial post-mortem, pathologist Dr Tomas Nemeth could not explain how Mr Doherty’s skull had a fracture and his shoulder had been dislocated, and he decided to call the state pathologist, Dr Marie Cassidy, to determine whether foul play had been involved.

In her findings, Dr Cassidy found that the head injury was consistent with a fall and contact with a stone on the ground following the fall.

She found Mr Doherty’s dislocated shoulder more difficult to explain, but having visited the site of the accident, she determined that Mr Doherty may have put his hand out to grab onto a wall. His shoulder would have become dislocated as a result of his hand getting caught between the wall and railings, due to the pressure of his body weight on the shoulder.

The post-mortem found that there was no hemorrhaging to the brain and that the head injury would not have caused death. The alcohol reading was high, and the left coronary artery was completely blocked. Dr Cassidy determined that death was due to a heart attack.

Gardaí also investigated the possibility of foul play and examined three cars that passed by the road, but none showed any evidence of damage caused by a collision with a pedestrian.

The inquest into Mr Doherty’s death heard that Mr Doherty had bought a naggin of brandy from Connolly’s pub at 7pm and was in good form.

John McManamon said he passed Mr Doherty on the left hand side of the road and noticed him holding onto a rail. He turned around to get cigarettes from a shop, and on his way back he looked out for Mr Doherty again and noticed he had fallen against the wall of the school.

He rang 999 at 7.25pm, and with the help of others, attempted CPR until the ambulance arrived. He told the coroner, Dr Eleanor Fitzgerald, that it would have been only four minutes between first seeing Mr Doherty and finding him on the road.

Paramedic Ronnie McDonnell told the inquest an ambulance arrived at the scene at 7.55pm that the crew performed CPR but were unsuccessful in reviving Mr Doherty and he was pronounced dead at the scene. He said if a defibrillator had been used earlier, it might have made a difference.

Dr Fitzgerald said that a thorough investigation had been carried out following Mr Doherty’s death and that she was satisfied he had died from natural causes. She added that a defibrillator may or may not have saved his life. She added that one should be located in the village as it could save a life if a similar situation were to happen again. Her sentiments were echoed by Sergeant Dermot Butler, who said it highlighted the need for defibrillators in rural areas.

Sympathy was extended to the family of Mr Doherty, and Mr McManamon and others who helped Mr Doherty were commended for their efforts.

Related topics:
Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice