Handcuffs get Ballyhaunis man off drink driving charge
An District Court judge dismissed a drink driving charge last week after having doubts surrounding the arrest of the man
Use of handcuffs get Ballyhaunis man off drink driving charge
A Ballyhaunis man escaped a drink driving charge last week after a District Court judge had doubts surrounding the man’s arrest.
Judge Mary Devins dismissed a drink driving charge against Stephen Jenkins of Bracklaghboy, Ballyhaunis, after conflicting evidence was heard surrounding whether the man was placed in handcuffs or not. However, Mr Jenkins received a driving ban for dangerous driving on the same night.
Mr Jenkins appeared before Claremorris District Court, sitting in Castlebar charged with drink driving on May 11, 2014 and three charges of dangerous driving on the same date.
The court heard that while responding to a call at 2.27am, Garda John Hughes and a fellow garda observed a Volkswagen Golf driving erratically and at speed at Hazelhill, Ballyhaunis. At Bracklaghboy village the gardaí noticed the car entering the hard shoulder before returning onto the road.
Garda Hughes said the car eventually pulled into the driveway of a house and on speaking to Mr Jenkins, he noticed the 28-year-old’s speech was slurred, he was unsteady on his feet and his eyes were glazed.
Mr Jenkins was holding a takeaway and told gardaí he had been at a party in a local bar earlier that night. He also admitted to having consumed alcohol. Mr Jenkins was arrested and brought to Claremorris Garda Station.
Garda Hughes said Mr Jenkins was then insulting and rude to the attending doctor asking her if she was ‘in any fit state’ to be taking a sample and if she had been drinking.
A urine sample showing 320mg of alcohol per 100ml of urine showed Mr Jenkins to be over four times the legal alcohol limit.
Doubt
Asked by defending solicitor Evan O’Dwyer if his client was handcuffed, Garda Hughes replied: ‘He was not handcuffed’.
Giving evidence, Mr Jenkins told Superintedent Joe Doherty that he was not sure who handcuffed him but that he remembers sitting in the back of the garda van with his hands cuffed behind his back.
Mr Jenkins told the court that he ‘just assumed it was procedure’.
Judge Devins was at a loss after hearing the conflicting evidence, asking ‘you’re leaving it to me to see who is telling the truth’?
The judge dismissed the drink driving charge after noting that she had a ‘small doubt’ about the issue of the handcuffs.
Judge Devins said there was sufficient evidence to convict Mr Jenkins of dangerous driving and he was convicted, receiving a €400 fine and a two year driving disqualification. He was fined a further €50 for failure to produce insurance within ten days of the incident.