Gearing up for a slow rebuilding process

Neill O'Neillplaceholder image
Neill O'Neill

In the final instalment of a two-part series, The Mayo News gives readers an exclusive insight into what the Government’s new economic adviser thinks about the recession and the way out of it

Gearing up for a slow rebuilding process

“THE drag from the property bubble bursting is beginning to recede and while 2007 and 2008 were bad in relation to the property bubble bursting in Ireland, the immediate problems brought on specifically by this are now beginning to ease.”

In discussing the property boom and Ireland’s way forward at the AGM of Westport Chamber of Commerce earlier this month, Dr Alan Ahearne informed all present that Ireland had built its way upwards in the Celtic Tiger era, and that an economy that was overly-dependent on a flourishing construction sector was always going to feel the consequences of the property bubble bursting, and that is exactly what happened.

The share of our national economy that was generated specifically by homebuilding and construction stood at six per cent in 1995, which was on par with an average across 12 EU nations at that time.

The problem began in subsequent years when this share, and with it a dependency on capital from the construction sector, rose and rose in Ireland – peaking at 17 per cent in 2006 – while it stayed around six per cent in the other European countries. In Ireland, Dr Ahearne said, this should never have risen above nine per cent. He further stated that the remainder – up to eight per cent of all money generated in the Irish economy over these years – was the proceeds of excess building and houses Ireland just didn’t need.

“In Spain, four per cent of GDP came from construction in 1995, which had risen to nine per cent by 2007,” he said. “At the same time we were at 17 per cent, so in Ireland we now need to build less houses and run off the excess housing stock.”

Dr Ahearne is predicting that house-building will contribute around three per cent of GDP in Ireland in 2009 – down 12 per cent over two years. He contends that the rest of the economy needs to grow rapidly to make up for the money that is now disappearing from the country’s coffers as a result, but added that rising unemployment is limiting spending, and ‘all these negatives make our economy contract’.

In his role as a Senior Economist in the International Finance Division of the Board of Governors of the Federal Reserve in Washington DC, Dr Ahearne undertook a task where he studied and analysed 44 international cases of housing booms ending in order to present findings to the board. So, how do we compare?

“What is happening in Ireland is worse than the typical boom to bust cycle, but our reaction is similarly different, so the hope is that the negative implications on one side will be cancelled out by the positive effects on the other,” he said. “Typically, prices fall for four or five years after they peak and then start to move up again. Japan was the exception to this – where they fell for 15 years – but in the five years after the bust it is usually the case that all the gains that were made are lost again, and prices and building both fall back to reasonable levels. In this, the economy stabilises and there is light at the end of the tunnel.”

Dr Ahearne also said that lowering and rising interest rates also come in cycles and affect inflation, and added that recent reductions in interest rates by the European Central Bank are a ‘powerful medicine’ for the economy, which is ‘doing more good than people realise’.

The way forward

“The first thing that needs to happen is that the Government need to get their own books in balance and stabilise the public finances,” according to Dr Ahearne, who has since taken up a post in the Department of Finance which will see him attempt to do just that.

The revenue coming from assets in Ireland – in the form of stamp duty etc – has dropped from over 15 per cent of all revenue generated, down to eight per cent, as a result of the declining housing market. This is a huge problem in itself, but add to it the fact that income from taxes was declining constantly during the boom years – down from 37 per cent in 1997 to 27 per cent in 2007 – due to widening tax bands, loopholes and the fact that 44 per cent of all workers paid no taxes.

“It would have been grand if the boom had continued,” said Dr Ahearne, “but it didn’t, and now there is a gaping hole there which needs to be filled. However, you cannot plug that hole in one year because hiking taxes and cutting spending just to balance the books will only kill the economy altogether, so it must be done over several years – up to five.”

If you are already fearing next week’s budget, look away now, because Dr Ahearne said that Ireland must brace itself for the painful and prolonged adjustments ahead, and added that the outlook for the near future is very bad.

“There is no magic wand to escape this and the country faces a painful adjustment period which could last beyond 2010,” he said. If that sounds worrying people should be aware that, according to Dr Ahearne, Exchequer figures so far this year are ‘atrocious’.

The hole in the Exchequer figures at present is nine-and-a-half per cent of Ireland’s GDP, which equates to €20 billion. The plan going forward is to have this below three per cent of GDP by 2013, which will be done by saving €4bn in 2010, €4bn in 2011, €3.5bn in 2012 and €3bn in 2013.

In order to reach this target the Government also needed to save €2bn this year – which was to be achieved through the public pension levy – but when the figures for the beginning of 2009 were analysed it became apparent that in order to keep the recovery plan on track, this would have to be revised upwards to €4.5bn for 2009. This is what has prompted next week’s budget.

The Government could have borrowed more – though it is now costing Ireland three per cent more for what we borrow than Germany – and returned to the savings and cuts programme next year, but Dr Ahearne feels that the plan to correct the public finances will be adhered to.

“We have to save €4.5bn this year and a further €4bn next year, and what is coming is rough but I feel the Government will stick to the plan. If the US economy bounces back then we will bounce back quicker and the natural buoyancy this will bring to revenues will negate the need for this recovery plan to be followed through to the end, which will ease the pain. We are a small open economy and are being clobbered by the downturn, but we will rise quickly with any upturn. In the meantime, current and capital spending will have to be cut. This has been done abroad in the past, but it only works where spending is cut across the board – with no exceptions – and is strictly adhered to.”

Indigenous industry looks set to become the driver of our growth, but we should continue to attract foreign direct investment, Dr Ahearne said, adding that the one legacy of the Celtic Tiger which stands in our favour as a nation is our low national debt, currently at 20 per cent of GDP by comparison with 100 per cent in Italy.

“There is anger about the situation our country finds itself in at present, but we need to replace anger with acceptance, fear with courage and despair with determination to beat this,” he concluded.

Dr Ahearne has taken leave of absence from his position as lecturer in economics in NUI Galway to act as advisor to the Minister for Finance, Mr Brian Lenihan.

Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice