Footballer jailed for punch during Gaelic club match


Victim, who lost the sight in one eye, says he was ‘let down’ by the GAA, which showed no concern for him after the assault
Victim, who lost the sight in one eye, ‘let down’ by GAA
A DAVITTS footballer who lost the sight of one eye following an assault during a game has criticised the GAA for not giving him any support in the aftermath of the incident.
Jonathan Clarke of Woodstock, Ballindine, lost 95 percent of the vision in his left eye after he was punched by a rival player while playing for Davitts against Moy Davitts in a league game in 2013.
Moy Davitts footballer Michael Prendergast pleaded guilty to assault causing harm to Mr Clarke on September 14, 2013, and was jailed for one year at Friday’s sitting of Castlebar Circuit Court.
In sentencing Mr Prendergast, Judge MacCabe said the fact that the injury was sustained in a game was irrelevant and that sport was not a ‘cloak for thuggery and violence’.
Mr Clarke was rushed to University College Hospital Galway, where he underwent emergency surgery for a ruptured eyeball and a detached retina. Despite numerous surgeries in both UCHG and the Mater hospital in Dublin, the retina kept detaching itself, resulting in loss of vision in the eye.
In his victim impact statement, Mr Clarke thanked his family, his girlfriend Aisling, his employers, Interchem and his Davitts team mates for their support, but he criticised the GAA, saying the organisation only contacted him to ask if he was making a claim.
‘No support’
“I have received no support from the GAA. Nobody came near me after the accident. A year later, they sent a risk-assessment person from Croke Park to see whether I was making a claim. Nobody expressed any concern for me. Nobody asked how I was. Nobody apologised from Moy Davitts, which is the club that Michael Prendergast played for. Nobody has come from the County Board. I have been completely let down by the GAA. I hope that other players never have to face what I have as far as the GAA is concerned,” he said.
Commenting on this, Judge MacCabe said the actions of the GAA ‘may or may not come as a surprise to listeners’ but it was of no surprise to him.
‘Unprovoked’
Mr Prendergast (35) of 40 Leicinn Village, Turlough, Castlebar, was sent off for the punch and pleaded guilty to the offence. The incident took place near the end of the game when Mr Prendergast punched Mr Clarke in the eye as he was retrieving the ball.
Mr Clarke said he still does not understand why the assault happened, as there was only two minutes left in the game. He said the game had not been ill-tempered and he could not have expected what happened.
“Michael Prendergast had no reason to have any bother with me. I had not been marking him during the match. I had no issue with him during the match. I still cannot understand why he decided to attack me. The incident was entirely unprovoked,” he said.
Shattered dreams
Mr Clarke was 23 at the time of the incident and described how his dreams have been shattered by going blind.
“While they say that I have a 95 percent loss of sight in my left eye, I am blind. I feel myself blind. I consider myself to be disabled. I will never be the same again,” he said.
“I now walk around on the brightest days in darkness. It is very difficult for me to try and comprehend this and that this will remain with me until I die.”
Mr Clarke said he has become very conscious of his appearance and people looking at the scarring under his eye socket. He said ‘even though my eye is there, it is gone’. He said he has become resigned to having to get a glass eye in the future for cosmetic effect.
Mr Clarke claimed that Mr Prendergast has never apologised to him, but defending counsel, Michael Bowman, SC said that after the game his client had enquired on the wellbeing of Mr Clarke and had apologised to the Davitts manager.
His client he said had also asked the Moy Davitts Chairman to enquire how Mr Clarke was, but it appeared that word had not filtered back to Mr Clarke. He added that once the matter became a criminal matter, the protocol was for the defendant to stay away from the victim.
‘Cowardly’
Mr Bowman told Judge Rory MacCabe that the assault was not justified but was different from an assault which might occur late at night and was not premeditated. He said it was as a result of adrenaline and a rush of blood to the head on the part of his client, whose actions have sullied both his name and the name of the club.
The court heard that Mr Prendergast was married a few weeks before the incident and works in Elvery Sports. Mr Bowman said his client knew what he did was wrong and had taken out a loan of €5,000 and was offering it as compensation to the victim.
Judge MacCabe said that he accepted that Mr Prendergast did not intend to injure Mr Clarke as badly as he did, but describing the punch as ‘cowardly’, he said Mr Prendergast has to accept the consequences.
An immediate custodial sentence, he said, was unavoidable, and he sentenced Mr Prendergast to two years’ imprisonment with the final 12 months suspended for 12 months.