Fine Gael accused of turning into second Fianna Fáil

FINE Gael were accused of abusing their power when they refused to compromise and allow Tony Deffely stay on the VEC board

Fine Gael accused of turning into second Fianna FΡil

Anton McNulty

FINE Gael were accused of abusing their power when they refused to compromise and allow Tony Deffely, a past President of the Teachers Union of Ireland to remain on the board of Mayo VEC.

At last week’s monthly meeting of Mayo County Council, Fine Gael whip Cllr Joe Mellett nominated two men and two women - Nonie McGee, Clodagh Geraghty, Pat Kilbane and Paddy Naughton - to fill the final four places on the board of Mayo VEC. The nomination of the two women was not opposed but Cllr Frank Durcan proposed that Tony Deffely, a teacher at Davitt College in Castlebar remain on the board and it was seconded by Cllr Blackie Gavin.

Despite pleas by members of Fianna FΡil and Independents to drop one of the men nominated by Fine Gael ‘in the interest of harmony’, they refused to do so. The decision not to reappoint Mr Deffely sees Paddy Naughton, the President of the GAA Connacht Council take up his seat on the board.

The decision by Fine Gael members not to compromise and go to the vote angered many of the councillors who supported Mr Deffely’s reappointment. Independent councillor Frank Durcan accused the party of ‘turning itself into a second Fianna FΡil party’ and they would pay for their decision to reject Mr Deffely in the ballot box.

Before the vote was taken, Fianna FΡil councillor Al McDonnell said they had formed a group to nominate another candidate but was told by the County Secretary, Mr John Condon that the grouping system was inappropriate in this case.

He explained that the Council had received legal advise by Fine Gael councillor Jarlath Munnelly which stated that the group voting system did not apply when appointing non-council members to a board. Mr Condon said he consulted with the Council’s legal adviser, Michael Browne who confirmed the view.

Cllr Al McDonnell asked the Fine Gael members who are in the majority in the Council to allow them to nominate one person to the VEC board in the interest of harmony and the spirit of the Council. He asked that they come up with a resolution rather than go to a vote and turn the matter into political point scoring.

However, Cllr Mellett said they had made their proposal and wanted to go with it. Independent councillor, Michael Holmes interjected and appealed to the Fine Gael members to drop one of their nominations for their own interests.

“I don’t know the gentlemen very well and I have no doubt they are capable of doing the job. But in the interest of their own party not to be seen abusing power I appeal for them to go three to one. You do not want to be seen abusing your power or taking advantage of power and I ask them to do down the road suggested by Cllr McDonnell. We need selfishness taken out of it,” he said.

However, despite the appeals Fine Gael decided to press on with their four nominations and a vote on Cllr Durcan’s motion to select Mr Deffely instead of Pat Kilbane was defeated by 18 votes to nine.

Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice