€20,000 for Ballina man after unprovoked attack
A Mayo League soccer player was awarded €20,640 in Ballina Circuit Civil Court last week, after he was attacked without provocation two-and-a-half years ago by three individuals whIlst walking home.
Soccer player gets €20,000 after vicious and unprovoked attack
A Mayo League soccer player was awarded €20,640 in Ballina Circuit Civil Court last week, after he was attacked without provocation two-and-a-half-years ago by three individuals whIlst walking home.
Declan O’Connor of 68 Rockwell, Killala Road, Ballina, was 25 years old when he and his girlfriend and her sister were walking home after a night out on May 21 2006.
On Pound Street they saw three men, one of whom shouted ‘hoods up’, and they ran across the road and began kicking, punching and head-butting him. One of them also threw a traffic cone at his head, while another went and got a shovel, which was used to fracture his ankle.
In February 2007 the three assailants, Mr Thomas Collins of 44 St Patrick’s Estate, Ballina; Mr Ernest Aschmann of 76 St Patrick’s Estate, Ballina, and Mr Milos Pjatak of 36 Castlefield Manor, Ballina, each received jail sentences in the Circuit Criminal Court, where Judge Raymond Groarke compared their actions to those of a ‘greyhound chasing a hare’, and called it a ‘horrible case’.
Mr O’Connor was hospitalised after the incident with injuries to his face, wrist and ribs, and an ankle fracture. A medical report stated that he had significant soft tissue injuries but had made a substantial recovery and was unlikely to require further treatment. Mr O’Connor told Judge Gerald B Keyes that he was off work for eight weeks after the attack and no longer liked walking home after nights out.
He said that he had met his assailants on the street on occasion in recent years, and they had sniggered at him. Sometimes, especially in cold weather, he found himself walking with a limp, he stated.
Ann Marie Courell then informed Judge Keyes that each of the assailants had portions of their terms of imprisonment suspended and part of the reason for this was that they were to pay their victim some compensation. To date he had not received this compensation – though €1,100 had been paid into his solicitor’s office by Milos Pjatak.
Judge Keyes concluded that this incident occurred for no reason and said that he ‘can’t understand why people do these things’.
“There is no excuse for this vicious attack where an implement was used,” he said. “This is absolutely disgraceful conduct and this man sustained bad injuries and has residual problems as a result.”
He awarded Mr O’Connor €20,000 in general damages and special damages and costs on top of this, saying that he was thinking of a higher figure. He said he makes no distinction between cases where an insurance company is involved and one where one is not.
The judgement was made against all three of Mr O’Connor’s assailants.