Estate agent found guilty of insurance fraud
A 33-year-old man was found guilty of deceiving Hibernian Insurance into paying him compensation for his BMW car
Ballyhaunis estate agent guilty of insurance fraud
A Ballyhaunis estate agent last week was found guilty of attempting to deceive Hibernian Insurance into paying him compensation for his missing BMW car at Castlebar Circuit Court last week.
Gerard O’Boyle (33) of Carrowreagh, Ballyhaunis maintained the vehicle valued at more than €50,000 had been stolen on the evening of October 8, 2008. The luxury car was later found across the road from his house in a quarry.
Under cross-examination, O’Boyle admitted that his financial situation was ‘up and down’, and he pointed out that his wife ‘was very demanding; she had expensive tastes’.
O’Boyle was also found guilty of having a forged driving licence in his possession and of using that licence to get insurance cover from Hibernian Insurance.
Ballyhaunis Sergeant Kieran McNicholas said that on November 12, 2008, he received an anonymous phone call stating that Mr O’Boyle’s stolen BMW was, in fact, hidden across the road from Mr O’Boyle’s home in a quarry.
The jury could not agree or make a decision on count one. That specific charge related to deceiving An Garda SíochΡna by reporting the alleged theft and making a false statement.
The defendant pleaded not guilty to all four charges. The jury began deliberating on Friday July 1 and continued its deliberations on Tuesday.
Judge Hunt told them that they had deliberated for sufficient time to allow them to record a majority verdict on the two remaining counts. An hour later, the foreperson of the jury explained that they had found Mr O’Boyle guilty by ten to two on count two but could not reach a verdict on count one.
Judge Hunt remanded Mr O’Boyle on bail until October 11 when the DPP should have a decision on whether to retrial Mr O’Boyle on count one. He said if there is no retrial they will then decide a date for sentencing.