Escalation of the protest causes shock

placeholder image

Last Wednesday's escalation of the protest against the Corrib Gas project caused shock in Erris.

In one of his best known poems, ‘Home Thoughts From Abroad’, Robert Browning wrote:

“Oh, to be in England

Now that April’s there

And whoever wakes in England

Sees, some morning, unaware,

That the lowest boughs and the brushwood sheaf

Round the elm-tree bole are in tiny leaf,

While the chaffinch sings on the orchard bough

In England, now!”

In the harsher environs of Erris we have our own signs of the arrival of April. The fishermen bring ashore their first hauls of lobster. The barnacle geese are departing in stylish formation for their breeding grounds in Greenland. The first cuckoo has been heard. The swallows have announced their arrival. Primroses and bluebells delicately embroider the landscape.

And protesters against the Corrib Gas project, refreshed though unchanged by their winter hibernation, have emerged out of the early morning mists at Glengad to impede the progress of a legitimate development that has been the subject of rigorous investigation for several years.

Last Wednesday’s performance was the first of what threatens to be a torrid summer in Kilcommon-Erris. More disturbingly, on Wednesday night, according to Superintendent Michael Larkin of Belmullet, up to 15 men, ‘wearing balaclavas and armed with iron bars and chains and other assorted weaponry’, entered the Shell compound at Glengad where they intimidated security staff and caused €30,000 damage to the site.

This escalation of the protest caused shock in Erris. A law-abiding community abhors even the penumbra of paramilitary-style activity.

The time has come to name some uncomfortable realities about the protest movement. I believe that the protesters receive media coverage out of proportion to their numbers. Seeing the situation as a modern re-run of the David and Goliath story misses out on its local complexity.

Every time I offer my analysis of the Corrib Gas controversy, some of the protesters question my right to express views contrary to theirs. I have no problem with their disagreement. A newspaper columnist must expect robust response. I do, however, have an issue with their questioning of my right to express my opinion. Freedom of expression is a hallmark of a civilised society.

Three groups claim to speak for the protesters: Shell to Sea, Pobal Chill Chomáin and Pobal Le Chéile. The last two moved away from Shell to Sea’s insistence that the terminal be located at sea. They proposed, halfway through the construction of the terminal at Bellanaboy, that it be located in the coastal area of Glinsk. They moved from one intransigent position to another and called it a compromise. Pobal Chill Chomáin and Pobal Le Chéile speak a more emollient language than Shell to Sea but, in their mutual intransigence, they are the one team wearing three different jerseys.

By now it is a small team. Pobal Chill Chomáin’s recent statement that opposition to the project is ‘mounting’ can be charitably classed as wishful thinking. I know that there are sincere people involved in the protest, their fears about safety often exacerbated by the hysterical Armageddon type rhetoric of some of their leaders.

All the protesters cannot, however, lay claim to the badge of sincerity. Among them are people who benefit commercially from the project, or rent accommodation to those working on it, or have worked on community developments sponsored by Shell. In a cynical world one might applaud their avaricious audacity. Those of us who try to live by an old-fashioned code of morality find it difficult to resist the conclusion that their opposition is literally laced by hypocrisy.

The small group of protesters is drawn into a kind of unity by their disparate concerns. A central difficulty in having dialogue with them is their leech-like adherence to dogmatic positions.

Among them are people who resist any change to traditional rural life. Some of them are serial opposers. They were against FÁS schemes in recent years. They are reminiscent of those who campaigned against rural electrification in the 1950’s and 1960’s.

Then there are those who oppose the project on ideological grounds. Their lonely insistence on the viability of unadulterated socialist economic theory has survived even the fall of the Berlin Wall in 1989. They believe that no multi-national company should benefit from the development of a country’s natural resources.

A third strand are the extreme environmentalists, mainly imported Eco-warriors, who contend that any interference with a natural landscape constitutes a secular sacrilege.

Finally there are the fanatical romantic nationalists whose vacuous mystical assertions about the sacred nature of the Erris landscape are unencumbered by an awareness of the complexity of our history or a realisation of the requirement to provide sustainable livelihoods for those who live there. Erris, according to this mindset, must be pure, even if it has to be poor.

I sense that most people in Erris, with varying degrees of enthusiasm, now support the Corrib Gas project. They accept that the Shell plan has undergone intensive investigation by the relevant state authorities and found to be in accordance with legal requirements. They acknowledge that the early protests have helped to ensure that high safety standards apply. They believe that Shell, since 2005, have made serious efforts to redress the consultation deficit that marked the early years of the project. They hope that the presence of the project in Erris will be the catalyst for further productive development. They reject allegations that the Gardaí and Courts system have not sought to be impartial in their duties. They recognise that Shell will be the major financial beneficiary of the project but hope that Minister Eamon Ryan will redress this imbalance in legislation governing future oil and gas exploration.

Where do we go from here? I believe there is need for a strong Government statement to the effect that, while it will always be respectful of peaceful protest, conducted lawfully, it will not be in thraldom to the tyranny of people who oppose illegally the informed conclusions of state agencies like An Bord Pleanála and the EPA.

The Corrib Gas project should have a high place on the Government’s agenda. It has the potential to make a huge contribution to Ireland’s energy needs in the next two decades.

Finally, I hope that the protest groups stop pussyfooting around the edges of the Government forum under the Chairmanship of Mr Joe Brosnan. Why not engage meaningfully, in a spirit of compromise, with Shell, Mayo County Council and Government Ministers? I retain the hope, however forlorn it often seems, that there are leaders among them who can rise to this honourable challenge. Why not stop wandering aimlessly around in what Patrick Kavanagh called ‘puddles of the past’ and instead strike out courageously for the shore?

Related topics:
Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice