End in sight for McHale Park saga but Mayor ‘disgusted’ with Town Manager

Leave it to Mr O’Brienplaceholder image
Leave it to Mr O’Brien

The ongoing saga over planning breaches at McHale Park in Castlebar appears to be moving towards a conclusion.

THE ongoing saga over planning breaches regarding the re-development of McHale Park in Castlebar appears to be moving towards a conclusion. At last Thursday’s monthly meeting of Castlebar Town Council two town councillors changed their minds and voted against pursuing a Section 140 motion to refuse planning permission for the controversial development.

However Mayor of Castlebar Michael Kilcoyne and Castlebar Town Manager Seamus Granahan were embroiled in a war of words over a court injunction which had been due to be served on the developers in relation to work around the media tower at the core of the row.

The contentious saga has been rumbling in the council since early September and, at a Castlebar Town Council meeting on September 10, councillors voted in favour of revoking planning permission for the development, which had a number of planning breaches in the vicinity of the media tower on the McHale Road side of the ground. That raised the possibility of the tower being knocked.

However, the execution of the revocation was held up due to various legal technicalities and the need for due process in relation to retention planning permission for the development.

At the outset of last Thursday’s meeting Seamus Granahan read out a letter received from solicitors acting for the Mayo GAA County Board - the developers of McHale Park - which gave a sworn undertaking not to work around the area in dispute. This, said Mr Granahan, greatly diminished the need for a court injunction to stop work at the site.

And when the Section 140 motion came up for discussion last Thursday two councillors, Labour’s Harry Barrett and Sinn Féin’s Thérése Ruane, who had voted initially in favour of the Section 140 for the councillors to revoke planning permission, changed their minds.

Cllrs Barrett and Ruane voted with Fine Gael trio Cllrs Ger Deere, Noreen Heston and Eugene McCormack to allow the town manager, Seamus Granahan, make the decision on the planning breaches on behalf of the council.

Independent councillors Frank Durcan and Michael Kilcoyne, who had proposed and seconded the initial motion, again voted to enforce the Section 140 which would give the councillors control of, and responsibility for the decision. They were joined by Fianna FΡil’s Blackie Gavin and Fine Gael’s Brendan Henaghan.

It will now be up to Seamus Granahan to decide on whether to accept revised plans submitted by architects for the Mayo GAA County Board, David O’Malley and Associates.

‘However, after the vote Cllr Frank Durcan claimed that some councillors had been ‘intimidated’, which Cllrs Barrett and Ruane denied this.

“I’m very disappointed that councillors have been intimidated and that they will be held legally responsible for costs if we carried out a Section 140. We’re not living in a democracy with that type of carry on.”

Cllr Thérése Ruane refuted the comments.

“I was not subject to intimidation. I spoke to planners and Sinn Féin councillors and got legal advice and made my own decision from that.”

Labour Councillor Harry Barrett added that he ‘praised Cllr Durcan for your tenacity’ which demonstrated that town councils ‘can still have a huge effect’.

“But the Section 140 notice has served its purpose in this situation. We have forced the County Board and their architects into making major changes.”

However, there were further tense exchanges between the Town Manager Seamus Granahan and Mayor Michael Kilcoyne over a proposed court injunction for the development.

At the October meeting of the council Mr Granahan had stated that he would be applying for an injunction through the courts to order the cessation of building work around the area in dispute.

However, at last Thursday’s meeting Mr Granahan stated that he was satisfied that the solicitor’s letter received by the council on behalf of the County Board made such an injunction unnecessary.

But, sitting beside him, Mayor Kilcoyne lashed out.

“You may be happy Manager, but I am not. You assured this council and residents of McHale Road that an injunction would be taken. I’m disgusted and I cannot say I will have any confidence in any assurances you make in the future,” said Mayor Kilcoyne.

Cllr Frank Durcan, who, with Michael Kilcoyne, has been very outspoken on the issue, differed from the Mayor’s stance.

“We’d be laughed out of court if we went after the Manager receiving such a legal undertaking. I’m satisfied that if we have any reason to go to court to get this injunction that the production of this letter would get an immediate injunction. But I still maintain that the manager should have moved on the injunction at the time of the breaches.”

Cllr Kilcoyne also took issue with Seamus Granahan over alleged non-compliance of Section 153 of the Planning Act of 2000. Cllr Kilcoyne alleged that the manager had 12 weeks in which to issue an enforcement notice from when he received a complaints from McHale Road residents. If he didn’t issue such a notice, argued Cllr Kilcoyne, he had two subsequent weeks to inform the residents which, said Cllr Kilcoyne, hadn’t been done.

“Initiating injunction proceedings is complying with the terms of the act,” argued Mr Granahan.

After further questioning from the Mayor, Cllr Eugene McCormack interjected.

“This aggressive interrogation is uncalled for. We should give more credence to the manager. If the manager went against legal advice and went to court, you Mayor would be the first to criticise him.”

A decision on the revised plans submitted by the County Board’s architects for the media tower is expected at the end of next week. Mayor Michael Kilcoyne has strongly intimated that he will get independent legal advice while if residents are still unsatisfied, they have recourse to An Bord PleanΡla.

Related topics:
Powered by
Register
Follow us
© 2026 Formpress Publishing LTD. All rights reserved.Cookie SettingsTerms and ConditionsPrivacy notice